Tricky NSR fish to identify.....atleast for me

[NSR Monger]

Caught this white one this year, not exactly sure if its a white or a mooneye, been hearing both, what do you guys think?? Also this other one from last year, is it a sauger or a saugeye, do not think its a walleye. Also they were both around 15 inches ROUGHLY. Thanks!!

[BGSH]

Caught this white one this year, not exactly sure if its a white or a mooneye, been hearing both, what do you guys think?? Also this other one from last year, is it a sauger or a saugeye, do not think its a walleye. Also they were both around 15 inches ROUGHLY. Thanks!!

Whitefish and walleye

[codywf]

100% rocky mountain whitefish and walleye

[nekred]

Are you serious!... both are obvious!...

as mentioned before RMW and Walleye...

Maybe peruse the regs...especially this page....

http://www.albertaregulations.ca/pdfs/fishing-regs/Sport-Fish-Identification.pdf

[TyreeUM]

saugeye

[BGSH]

saugeye

WALLEYE LOL :fighting0030:

[bigd]

100% rocky mountain whitefish and walleye

ditto, 110%

[NSR Monger]

haha thanks guys, those were my initial thoughts but it seemed most people did not think it was a walleye so I believed them! Same with the White, most people told me a mooneye but I was pretty sure that it was a white, look how WHITE it is lol nice looking fish though, that was my first white.

[BGSH]

haha thanks guys, those were my initial thoughts but it seemed most people did not think it was a walleye so I believed them! Same with the White, most people told me a mooneye but I was pretty sure that it was a white, look how WHITE it is lol nice looking fish though, that was my first white.

Did you keep them, did they taste good?

[codywf]

not a personal attack on the OP, but This is why I believe that to acquire a fishing licence people should have to pass a fish identification test and general rules test. I know some people that have been fishing for 20 years (almost my age) and they don't have a clue what kind of trout they have caught.

[NSR Monger]

LOL ok now the more I look at the identification page it is clear that its a whitefish but the "walleye" does show characteristics of both fish! The eyes are not "glazed" like the walleye and the fin looks more like a sauger because its not so rounded. Though the skin looks more like a walleye then a sauger. I am pretty amateur at the river though, just going by the alberta identification page......

[BGSH]

LOL ok now the more I look at the identification page it is clear that its a whitefish but the "walleye" does show characteristics of both fish! The eyes are not "glazed" like the walleye and the fin looks more like a sauger because its not so rounded. Though the skin looks more like a walleye then a sauger. I am pretty amateur at the river though, just going by the alberta identification page......

Its no where near a sauger, its a typical N.s.r walleye

[NSR Monger]

Yeah Cody I can agree I need more knowledge, but that's what I am trying to do by starting this post. I used to fish with my grandparents and uncle when I was much younger, last year my passion got re-ignited due to getting to fish a lake on Salt Spring Island B.C. last September. Trying to learn as much as I can as quickly as I can!

[nekred]

i may have been a bit harsh... but when it comes to fishing if you aenot sure...put it back...

I have had times when i caught a fish in new waters and had to take picture and go identify it... but mostly because it was very unexpected...

Turned out it was a cisco...

[nof60]

#1 is a whitefish

#2 is a saugeye, a hybrid of sauger and walleye displaying spots on the dorsal and reduced white area on the lower tail

Congrats, not many have caught a saugeye

[pickrel pat]

not a personal attack on the OP, but This is why I believe that to acquire a fishing licence people should have to pass a fish identification test and general rules test. I know some people that have been fishing for 20 years (almost my age) and they don't have a clue what kind of trout they have caught.

why would someone need to identify fish if they planned on relesing everything? why? why?:sHa_sarcasticlol:

[NSR Monger]

Ok BGSH I'll take your word for it. I've seen some of your posts and pic's, I'm positive you have much more experience than me on the river. Do you have a pic of a NSR Sauger you could post?

[BGSH]

Ok BGSH I'll take your word for it. I've seen some of your posts and pic's, I'm positive you have much more experience than me on the river. Do you have a pic of a NSR Sauger you could post?

Sure i have a couple hang on

[pickrel pat]

from the almost absent white spot on the tail, with the darker black flecking, id say saugeye.

[nof60]

saugeye

[ReconWilly]

I see what looks like a saugeye, based on the spots on the fins and the color of the fish is also interesting. Cool catch, neat.

[NSR Monger]

damn I dunno who is right! BGSH and nof60 both seem like they know their stuff! Personally I really think it is a saugeye due to having characteristics of both but as previously stated I'm quite inexperienced and I have never caught a Walleye from the river unless this is one lol

[Redfrog]

Anyone else getting tired of these questions? Why can't these people be born experts like the rest of us?:snapoutofit:

[ReconWilly]

Anyone else getting tired of these questions? Why can't these people be born experts like the rest of us?:snapoutofit:

No.:snapoutofit:

[Jasonp]

Sorry bgsh its a Saugeye for sure.. Take this from the nsr walleye master :)

[ReconWilly]

Sorry bgsh its a Saugeye for sure.. Take this from the nsr walleye master :)

Ohhhhhhhhh we have a challenger!!:fighting0074:

[BGSH]

Sorry bgsh its a Saugeye for sure.. Take this from the nsr walleye master :)

I am still going with a rocky mountain white and a walleye.

[ReconWilly]

I am still going with a rocky mountain white and a walleye.
:party0052:

[pike_king780]

Whitefish and Walleye definitely!

[addictedfisherman]

Rocky mountain whitefish and a Saugeye

[nekred]

here is a saugeye id link... and on further inspection of photo I am on fence between saugeye and walleye...

Definitely not a saugeye due to the eye... but could be a walleye with some saugeye genes from a previous generation....


http://www.google.ca/imgres?imgurl=http://www.wildlifedepartment.com/fishing/fishid/Saugeye.jpg&imgrefurl=http://www.wildlifedepartment.com/fishing/fishid/saugeye.htm&h=282&w=547&sz=33&tbnid=PjyN8HgQWGeSuM:&tbnh=62&tbnw=120&prev=/search%3Fq%3Dsaugeye%26tbm%3Disch%26tbo%3Du&zoom=1&q=saugeye&docid=I2AKV6D6UHvYtM&hl=en&sa=X&ei=aNiiT9-gFcLy2QW36LjPCA&ved=0CDEQ9QEwAg&dur=203

[voidspace]

whitefish and saugeye

[codywf]

I'll argue walleye due to the white on the tail, no site that has saugeye identification list the white on the tail

[fish gunner]

white fish and a walleye, white spot on tail is the identification, F&W will not be using the other features as a possible hybrid.

[pike_king780]

I'll argue walleye due to the white on the tail, no site that has saugeye identification list the white on the tail

Exactly x2

[nof60]

Got this "Saugeye are a cross of the walleye and
sauger. The dark bars on the dorsal fin are the
best identifying characteristic for this fish. Sharp
canine teeth, dark blotches on the sides, and a
white tip on the lower tail also help identify the
saugeye."

from here http://www.dnr.state.oh.us/portals/9/pdf/pub358.pdf

Not enough white for a walleye

[Bow flyman]

Rocky mountain whitefish and sauger.

[TyreeUM]

I'll argue walleye due to the white on the tail, no site that has saugeye identification list the white on the tail

that is because not all saugeye have white on their tail, but a lot of them do...

[BBJTKLE&FISHINGADVENTURES]

First Picture is of a Rocky Mountain Whitefish
Second is a Saugeye , as it doesnt have the define markings of a Walleye or of Sauger it has both of each

[MoFugger21]

The second one looks like a pickeral to me....... :)

[huffy]

I see some of the same old comments about know your fish before you fish, but there seems to be a lot of debate on what fish #2 is, even between the self-proclaimed experts. Myself, I have no opinion!:argue2:

[BBJTKLE&FISHINGADVENTURES]

I see some of the same old comments about know your fish before you fish, but there seems to be a lot of debate on what fish #2 is, even between the self-proclaimed experts. Myself, I have no opinion!:argue2:

Self proclaimed Experts ? I dont think so . Its your responsibility to know your Identification . If you dont and you get caught that could become very costly and lost your right to fish among losing your gear , boat , truck , etc .

So US SELF PROCLAINED EXPERTS have a very valid point .

[codywf]

Well ill just agree with saugeye as i don't fish the river that much, but regardless those of us who said walleye wouldn't get in any trouble because we would throw it back.

[TyreeUM]

I see some of the same old comments about know your fish before you fish, but there seems to be a lot of debate on what fish #2 is, even between the self-proclaimed experts. Myself, I have no opinion!:argue2:

Do the regs differ from walleye to sauger to saugeye? The problem is when they can't identify fish that look nothing alike. There are a lot of people that can't properly identify species of suckers, but they know they are suckers. When people can't tell the difference between a whitefish, perch, walleye, or pike...that is a serious problem.

[huffy]

Self proclaimed Experts ? I dont think so . Its your responsibility to know your Identification . If you dont and you get caught that could become very costly and lost your right to fish among losing your gear , boat , truck , etc .

So US SELF PROCLAINED EXPERTS have a very valid point .

I think you missd the humour/sarcasm in my post. I was not saying people shouldn't know their fish, just commenting on the large numbers of people with differing opinions on what fish number 2 is! Didn't intend to offend. Sense of humour is a wonderful thing!

[huntsfurfish]

Saugeye

[Jasonp]

I am still going with a rocky mountain white and a walleye.

Look at the coloring and the spots on the fins, walleye don't have those, the white mark isn't as prodominate either.

U coming with me on saturday?

[voidspace]

Do the regs differ from walleye to sauger to saugeye? The problem is when they can't identify fish that look nothing alike. There are a lot of people that can't properly identify species of suckers, but they know they are suckers. When people can't tell the difference between a whitefish, perch, walleye, or pike...that is a serious problem.

You can keep sauger from the nsr.

"from Highway 22/39 (Drayton Valley) downstream to the Alberta/Saskatchewan border
River Only Open all year – Mountain Whitefish limit 5 over 30 cm; Walleye limit 0; Sauger limit 0 from Apr. 1 to May 14; Sauger limit 3 from May 15 to Mar. 31; Pike limit 1 over 63 cm; Burbot limit 10; Goldeye limit 10; Lake Sturgeon limit 0."

[Geezle]

Second pic is a saugeye...though the walleye genes in that one seem most dominant.

[nof60]

You can keep sauger from the nsr.

"from Highway 22/39 (Drayton Valley) downstream to the Alberta/Saskatchewan border
River Only Open all year – Mountain Whitefish limit 5 over 30 cm; Walleye limit 0; Sauger limit 0 from Apr. 1 to May 14; Sauger limit 3 from May 15 to Mar. 31; Pike limit 1 over 63 cm; Burbot limit 10; Goldeye limit 10; Lake Sturgeon limit 0."

So I guess if you want to eat it its a sauger, if you want to release it its a walleye.

I was working between Inuvik and tuktoyuktuk a few years ago. Their is a herd of reindeer there that is owned by a family from Tuk. They were herded there a long time ago and originated in Europe. Anyway I asked an Inuit guy I worked with how to tell the diff between a caribou and a reindeer. He said because the reindeer were privately owned you could not shoot them. So if it was alive it was a reindeer. If he had shot it it was a caribou. Same thing here.

Where would a Saugeye fit in the regs?

[Sundancefisher]

Rocky Mountain Whitefish and a WalleyeXSauger Cross...my bet.

[voidspace]

I release all fish from the nsr, or anywhere else I fish as I c&r.

[DiabeticKripple]

im wondering if you can legally keep saugeye

[BeeGuy]

It may be a saugeye.

If you send me both fillets, I will run a digestive analysis on them and send you the results.

[curtis_rak]

This is an NSR Sauger.... a nice one too caught last September near Rundle Park

They have a very defined, blotchy pattern compared to a walleye.


http://i19.photobucket.com/albums/b164/curtis_rak/Fishing/StrathconaCounty-20110924-00300.jpg

[Geezle]

This is an NSR Sauger.... a nice one too caught last September near Rundle Park

They have a very defined, blotchy pattern compared to a walleye.


http://i19.photobucket.com/albums/b164/curtis_rak/Fishing/StrathconaCounty-20110924-00300.jpg

Sauger? I see no sauger? :evilgrin:

[Alberta Bigbore]

Fish #2 is a Saugeye for sure. Lots of the buggers in NSR, nothing new.

[Mariko's Rod]

This is an NSR Sauger.... a nice one too caught last September near Rundle Park

They have a very defined, blotchy pattern compared to a walleye.


http://i19.photobucket.com/albums/b164/curtis_rak/Fishing/StrathconaCounty-20110924-00300.jpg

Nice work man!

[Mike_W]

Sauger? I see no sauger? :evilgrin:

Lol I was thinking the same thing!:evilgrin:

[curtis_rak]

haha ;)

[Bigdad013]

not a personal attack on the OP, but This is why I believe that to acquire a fishing licence people should have to pass a fish identification test and general rules test. I know some people that have been fishing for 20 years (almost my age) and they don't have a clue what kind of trout they have caught.

I assume you would be first in line for the fish id TEST?

[Lefty-Canuck]

Sauger? I see no sauger? :evilgrin:

I am guessing Rundle Park will be added to your river fishing rotation Geezle? :)






......pssst.....I'll meet you there :)

LC

[Mark H]

That fish is a saugeye, and.... ( Best Guide) just got demoted to "average at best" guide. :)

[curtis_rak]

I marked about a dozen 10-12' deep holes between the Goldbar launch and the Rundle park island. Everyone of them has walleye and sauger in them. Also caught a small burbot in one. Just waiting to get lucky and catch a sturgeon one day (fingers crossed).

In mid-september you can't keep the fish off around those ddeeper holes, and the water is at about 8 feet of visibility.

[BBJTKLE&FISHINGADVENTURES]

I think you missd the humour/sarcasm in my post. I was not saying people shouldn't know their fish, just commenting on the large numbers of people with differing opinions on what fish number 2 is! Didn't intend to offend. Sense of humour is a wonderful thing!

Pretty difficult to read sarcasm .

[codywf]

I assume you would be first in line for the fish id TEST?

gladly, I'll be the first to admit that I have never seen a saugeye, yet I'm well aware of both species, my knowledge of identifying a fish would have told me to put it back ( as i would with any NSR fish), When people can't tell the difference between types of trout, or a walleye and perch, thats when we have a problem.

I'm not suggesting we throw pictures or tiger,splake, cuttbow, saugeye. A basic test to ensure the average fisherman is aware of the main differences between certain fish.

[tonypower]

Just thought I would add my two cents. Its a pickerel. LOL!!

[TyreeUM]

gladly, I'll be the first to admit that I have never seen a saugeye, yet I'm well aware of both species, my knowledge of identifying a fish would have told me to put it back ( as i would with any NSR fish), When people can't tell the difference between types of trout, or a walleye and perch, thats when we have a problem.

I'm not suggesting we throw pictures or tiger,splake, cuttbow, saugeye. A basic test to ensure the average fisherman is aware of the main differences between certain fish.

If someone is ignorant enough to keep a fish they are not even able to identify, I am not sure an identification test is really going to curb these people from poaching...maybe im wrong though.

[huntsfurfish]

That fish is a saugeye, and.... ( Best Guide) just got demoted to "average at best" guide. :)

:)LOL 2nd that

[ddddd05]

Nice Rocky that is a good sized one forsure.

As for the other fish, definitely not a Sauger because it has the white spot on the tail. I agree with the other guys that said Saugeye because it has the black spots on the dorsal fins (although they are not very clear).

Where on the NSR did you catch them? I've never caught a RMW out of the NSR. I've never caught a Burbot out of the NSR either but I saw a guy catch one tonight.

[BBJTKLE&FISHINGADVENTURES]

Where on the NSR did you catch them? I've never caught a RMW out of the NSR. I've never caught a Burbot out of the NSR either but I saw a guy catch one tonight.

Its getting kinda late now but if you go further up river where water remains colder you cant damn near keep em off your hook , Kinda like Goldeye when water warms up .

[EP2]

If someone is ignorant enough to keep a fish they are not even able to identify, I am not sure an identification test is really going to curb these people from poaching...maybe im wrong though.

When it comes down to rocky mountain whitefish (admittedly rarer in Edmonton than say---Rocky ;) ) versus sucker, that is a pretty glaringly obvious case of misidentification.

They weren't not identifying the white, they were positively identifying it as a sucker. Could have ended up booted into the bushes if the person was different.

I am all down for a test. However, what do you make the law--100%, 90, 85, 75. At what point do you say: sure you got X wrong, but now you know, or, go home, read this, and come back tomorrow.


Same reason why guys over 65 should still need some sort of license. I am sure there are those that do not go out and get new regs every year. Paying a few bucks ensures they have to go through the process (even if they buy online, they go right past the regulations).

[buckbrushoutdoors]

You have a negative comment for every thread yet you cannot identify a whitefish. Your obviously a complete fool. Way to go

[NSR Monger]

You have a negative comment for every thread yet you cannot identify a whitefish. Your obviously a complete fool. Way to go

funny how the entire forums only way to make fun of me is that I couldnt not identify a couple fish.

so original, really hurts my feelings

[BGSH]

funny how the entire forums only way to make fun of me is that I couldnt not identify a couple fish.

so original, really hurts my feelings

Then quit hating on everybody and you know what they say what goes around comes around, you bring it all upon yourself.

[NSR Monger]

Then quit hating on everybody and you know what they say what goes around comes around, you bring it all upon yourself.

I dont really care if people make fun of me cuz i couldn't identify a whitefish or a saugeye. Every time someone wants to rip in to me they use that, it doesnt bother me, its hardly original anymore.

also if you re-read the thread I am for sure not the only person to have a hard time identifying the second fish.

[BGSH]

I dont really care if people make fun of me cuz i couldn't identify a whitefish or a saugeye. Every time someone wants to rip in to me they use that, it doesnt bother me, its hardly original anymore.

You bash the geeks for keeping one fish out of a million, you bash me all the time which makes for great entertainment and you bash many others as well, grow up man.

[NSR Monger]

You bash the geeks for keeping one fish out of a million, you bash me all the time which makes for great entertainment and you bash many others as well, grow up man.

lol you keep going!!!!!

do you actually think that is the biggest burbot ever caught in the world!?! you dont think anyone has EVER in the HISTORY of the earth caught a bigger burbot?? its only the biggest burbot someone had to kill for no reason just to put on their wall. like cmon man give your head a shake.

The official world record for pike is roughly 55lbs, though there is cases reported from the 1920's in europe of 80-90lb pike. I'm sure this is the case with burbot and every other species. Not everyone cares about nor thinks about a WR when they catch a big fish. Some of us would just go "holy smokes thats a big fish!!!!!" (take some pics and let it go) without ever considering, hey If i kill this for no reason I can get it verified .

I'll let this end, but not if you keep going after I have tried to stop

[Penner]

Also a Rocky Mountain White and a Saugeye no doubt about it.

[Fishnafterwork]

do you actually think that is the WR for a burbot!?!?! you dont think anyone has EVER in the HISTORY of the earth caught a bigger burbot?? its only the biggest burbot someone had to kill for no reason just to put on their wall. like cmon man give your head a shake.

The official world record for pike is roughly 55lbs, though there is cases reported from the 1920's in europe of 80-90lb pike. I'm sure this is the case with burbot and every other species. Not everyone cares about nor thinks about a WR when they catch a big fish. Some of us would just go "holy smokes thats a big fish!!!!!" (take some pics and let it go) without ever considering, hey If i kill this for no reason I can get it verified .

I'll let this end, but not if you keep going after I have tried to stop



Ethics police??? What buisness is it of yours if the geek keeps any or all of his fish?.... He is well within his legal rights...!!
If you choose to not keep your fish that is your choice!!
And leave people who choose to keep theirs alone!
I know I know your just trying to educate the rest of us on caring for fish...
Like in your rainbow trout thread laying on the rocks....
I don't care if you lay your fish on the rocks but don't cast stones if you yourself are not without fault... It's not just about not bring able to Id a fish but others arnt trying to pick on everything you do or say... Cause they are intimidated of u attacking them.. You clearly have an issue understanding the differences in engaging in conversation and calling people out... For someone so new to fishing that make so many mistakes u sure have a lot of advise for the amature geek about the few things u have learned.... This is not conversation or discussion or education or whatever u wanna call it .... It is straight up abuse... I would advise you to take a bit more time thinking before u type as I have never herd suck verbal diahareea as what comes from u & never have I seen anyone write anything like "kill u for the wall" or "who's fillet knife is bigger" except for you and as it appears you have made a few enemies I'm sure a fee people are just waiting for u to slip up

Bottom line keeping a burbot - perfectly legal
Some of your comments - very borderline

[keeks]

Fish 1.....Sturgeon.
Fish 2.....Golden Trout. Very common in the NSR.

[RavYak]

FFS BGSH and Monger. Kiss and make up already you bunch of over dramatic attention *****s...

[Graffy91]

funny how the entire forums only way to make fun of me is that I couldnt not identify a couple fish.

so original, really hurts my feelings

Seriously dude, you're worse than a highschool girl.

[Vigsy]

Seriously dude, you're worse than a highschool girl.
actually i find highschool girls much more intelligent and mature :)

[Graffy91]

actually i find highschool girls much more intelligent and mature :)

Hence why I said he's worse haha.

Never seen a guy like to bitch, complain, and diminish people more when he handles fish like their nothing but yet seems to bitch at other people for it.

:argue2:

[EZM]

lol you keep going!!!!!

do you actually think that is the biggest burbot ever caught in the world!?! you dont think anyone has EVER in the HISTORY of the earth caught a bigger burbot?? its only the biggest burbot someone had to kill for no reason just to put on their wall. like cmon man give your head a shake.

The official world record for pike is roughly 55lbs, though there is cases reported from the 1920's in europe of 80-90lb pike. I'm sure this is the case with burbot and every other species. Not everyone cares about nor thinks about a WR when they catch a big fish. Some of us would just go "holy smokes thats a big fish!!!!!" (take some pics and let it go) without ever considering, hey If i kill this for no reason I can get it verified .

I'll let this end, but not if you keep going after I have tried to stop

Monger - seems a bit harsh to be attacking someone's friend for catching a world record fish or two...... anyone can do it right???? pretty lucky guys, both brothers seem to have luck .......... lol ...... your comments are misdirected.

Maybe a good job, congratulations would be the normal thing to do ..... but to deplete someones achievement is pretty classless. These guys put in time and effort and deserve recognition and respect.

Forgive me for saying so - I'd suggest you might be out of line.

[Vigsy]

Hence why I said he's worse haha.

Never seen a guy like to bitch, complain, and diminish people more when he handles fish like their nothing but yet seems to bitch at other people for it.

:argue2:

crazy how us 17 year olds are baffled at the immaturity of a grown "man" like him

[OneGirlWolfPack]

crazy how us 17 year olds are baffled at the immaturity of a grown "man" like him

You're 17? I never would have guessed that.

Very well said EZM. :)

[Lefty-Canuck]

I dont really care if people make fun of me cuz i couldn't identify a whitefish or a saugeye. Every time someone wants to rip in to me they use that, it doesnt bother me, its hardly original anymore.


http://i1220.photobucket.com/albums/dd460/lefty-canuck/funnies/PS_0066_PLANET_t.jpg

LC :)

[Geezle]

actually i find highschool girls much more intelligent and mature :)

"That's what I love about high school girls...I get older...they stay the same age."

[Vigsy]

You're 17? I never would have guessed that.



whys that ha? yep 17 for another 4 months

[Lefty-Canuck]

whys that ha? yep 17 for another 4 months

Could be that she likes her meat a little bit more well done....and not so tender :)

LC :)

[Bhflyfisher]

crazy how us 17 year olds are baffled at the immaturity of a grown "man" like him

they both need to just nut up and get over it. I totally agree with you though. I'm 17 too, my little brother who's 14 acts like these 2 dorks.

[Vigsy]

they both need to just nut up and get over it. I totally agree with you though. I'm 17 too, my little brother who's 14 acts like these 2 dorks.

Ya its pretty sad... but i dont mind best guide ha its monger who needs a tune up.

[DiabeticKripple]

18 years here, sometimes act like 10.

but the name calling in here is junior high. i wouldnt class it as high school. in high school they use baaaad words like c$%t

[Bhflyfisher]

Ya its pretty sad... but i dont mind best guide ha its monger who needs a tune up.

Again agree with you there as well. BUT I could still do without the hundreds of pictures of the same size walleye though...

[Vigsy]

Again agree with you there as well. BUT I could still do without the hundreds of pictures of the same size walleye though...

meh no big deal to me, if it were all the same fish maybe.. but after fishing with him enough times being right beside him using the same thing and him outfishing me 3-1 over and over il give the guy the credit he deserves.

[BGSH]

meh no big deal to me, if it were all the same fish maybe.. but after fishing with him enough times being right beside him using the same thing and him outfishing me 3-1 over and over il give the guy the credit he deserves.

LOL thanks bro, i have the stuff i owe you as well, sorry could not make it out there on Sunday, will hopefully get together soon and maybe catch some more fish.

[Vigsy]

LOL thanks bro, i have the stuff i owe you as well, sorry could not make it out there on Sunday, will hopefully get together soon and maybe catch some more fish.

sounds good.

[OneGirlWolfPack]

whys that ha? yep 17 for another 4 months

You just come across as really mature on here. :)

[Vigsy]

You just come across as really mature on here. :)

Well thank ya, some people (monger) should take a few tips.

[Graffy91]

"That's what I love about high school girls...I get older...they stay the same age."

Hahahahahaha knew this was coming. :sHa_shakeshout:

[NSR Monger]

does no one else see the irony in talking smack to me because you dont like what I say or do, when that is the exact reason I talk smack to some of you guys??? So really you are doing the EXACT same thing I am doing.......voicing your opinion on a public forum........So anyone who has ripped into me or talked smack to me, you are no better then I am. Remember that!

[Bhflyfisher]

meh no big deal to me, if it were all the same fish maybe.. but after fishing with him enough times being right beside him using the same thing and him outfishing me 3-1 over and over il give the guy the credit he deserves.

No no no. I totally give him credit for catching all the fish he does. I'm not saying that. I was saying more along the lines of catching 30 20" walleye, and taking a picture of everyone of them just to prove he caught them. He's very skilled and I don't doubt that he's catching more fish then most of the members on here. But at what point do you stop taking hundreds of the same pictures. He's obviously got the skill, which he has proved. I'm not doubting that.

[Vigsy]

No no no. I totally give him credit for catching all the fish he does. I'm not saying that. I was saying more along the lines of catching 30 20" walleye, and taking a picture of everyone of them just to prove he caught them. He's very skilled and I don't doubt that he's catching more fish then most of the members on here. But at what point do you stop taking hundreds of the same pictures. He's obviously got the skill, which he has proved. I'm not doubting that.

If thats the case whats the point of putting any trout or other species you catch up? We have all seen fish like that before. Now to be clear im not saying dont, I like all posts and it doesnt bother me if they look the same. Its a fishing forum and if you go fishing and catch fish that are the same as your last post, good on ya! Post em up who cares good posts with lots of pics are what make this forum awsome. And if we all start worrying if our posts look like another then its just going to go downhill real quick. Point being if you go fishing catch fish and take pictures, post em.

[NSR Monger]

If thats the case whats the point of putting any trout or other species you catch up? We have all seen fish like that before. Now to be clear im not saying dont, I like all posts and it doesnt bother me if they look the same. Its a fishing forum and if you go fishing and catch fish that are the same as your last post, good on ya! Post em up who cares good posts with lots of pics are what make this forum awsome. And if we all start worrying if our posts look like another then its just going to go downhill real quick. Point being if you go fishing catch fish and take pictures, post em.

yeah but BGSH thinks that because he posts the most pics, he catches the most fish.....also he thinks if you dont post 100 pics of every fish like he does that means you dont catch any fish at all........and you say its ok as long as its not the same fish for 5 pics.........go look at some of his threads, literally 3-5 pics of the exact same fish, there is 15 pics but of only 3 fish, then he says he caught 45 that day.

[Graffy91]

yeah but BGSH thinks that because he posts the most pics, he catches the most fish.....also he thinks if you dont post 100 pics of every fish like he does that means you dont catch any fish at all........and you say its ok as long as its not the same fish for 5 pics.........go look at some of his threads, literally 3-5 pics of the exact same fish, there is 15 pics but of only 3 fish, then he says he caught 45 that day.

WHO CARES.


WE'RE HERE FOR FISHING, NOT TO BE DRAMA QUEENS LIKE YOU.

:argue2::argue2::argue2::argue2:

[NSR Monger]

WHO CARES.


WE'RE HERE FOR FISHING, NOT TO BE DRAMA QUEENS LIKE YOU.

:argue2::argue2::argue2::argue2:

he has constantly told me I catch no fish cuz i dont post as many pics as him.....how am I the drama queen, why do you guys like jerking off BGSH so much

[AK47]

back to original question: No doubt what first fish is, and second is saugeye. As with all hybrids they can take more or less traits from each species, thus none of two saugeyes will look exactly the same. But no walleye will have black spots on dorsal fin and no sauger will have white spot on the tail or no black markings on anal fin. Thus - it is saugeye or wallger:)

[NSR Monger]

back to original question: No doubt what first fish is, and second is saugeye. As with all hybrids they can take more or less traits from each species, thus none of two saugeyes will look exactly the same. But no walleye will have black spots on dorsal fin and no sauger will have white spot on the tail or no black markings on anal fin. Thus - it is saugeye or wallger:)

lol sorry dude, this is a 6 month old thread, the question has been answered a long time ago, thread got brought back to the top cuz thats the only way people can try to offend me on this forum......cuz I asked what kind of fish those are hahahaha omg I'm so offended

[Vigsy]

yeah but BGSH thinks that because he posts the most pics, he catches the most fish.....also he thinks if you dont post 100 pics of every fish like he does that means you dont catch any fish at all........and you say its ok as long as its not the same fish for 5 pics.........go look at some of his threads, literally 3-5 pics of the exact same fish, there is 15 pics but of only 3 fish, then he says he caught 45 that day.

Your not quite the brightest are you? You dont even deserve a response anymore.

[MoFugger21]

http://i742.photobucket.com/albums/xx61/MoFugger21/picard_facepalm.jpg

http://i742.photobucket.com/albums/xx61/MoFugger21/images2.jpg

[Bhflyfisher]

If thats the case whats the point of putting any trout or other species you catch up? We have all seen fish like that before. Now to be clear im not saying dont, I like all posts and it doesnt bother me if they look the same. Its a fishing forum and if you go fishing and catch fish that are the same as your last post, good on ya! Post em up who cares good posts with lots of pics are what make this forum awsome. And if we all start worrying if our posts look like another then its just going to go downhill real quick. Point being if you go fishing catch fish and take pictures, post em.

I completely understand where you're coming from. I dont want to get into another discussion on this thread about pictures. If you want to have a good conversation about it, feel free to pm me. I'd be happy to discuss.

[huntsfurfish]

Wow, I think both need a time out!

[MoFugger21]

http://i742.photobucket.com/albums/xx61/MoFugger21/motherofgod.jpg


This thread is ridiculous....


I hereby change the theme of this thread to: ADORABLE KITTENS.


Enjoy!


http://i742.photobucket.com/albums/xx61/MoFugger21/too-cute-kitten_3792641_lrg.jpg

http://i742.photobucket.com/albums/xx61/MoFugger21/St-Louis-Most-Adorable-Kitten-Ashley-272x300.jpg

http://i742.photobucket.com/albums/xx61/MoFugger21/marcus_serven2-3.jpg

[MoFugger21]

http://i742.photobucket.com/albums/xx61/MoFugger21/images-1.jpg

http://i742.photobucket.com/albums/xx61/MoFugger21/cute_kittens_sleeping.jpg

http://i742.photobucket.com/albums/xx61/MoFugger21/cute_kitten_wants_a_hug.jpg

[MoFugger21]

http://i742.photobucket.com/albums/xx61/MoFugger21/baby-kittens-waking-up.jpg

http://i742.photobucket.com/albums/xx61/MoFugger21/Adorable-lil-Kittens-cute-kittens-9781800-1024-768.jpg

http://i742.photobucket.com/albums/xx61/MoFugger21/Adorable-Kitties12.jpg

[MoFugger21]

http://i742.photobucket.com/albums/xx61/MoFugger21/Adorable-Kittens-3-cats-18476211-448-336.jpg

http://i742.photobucket.com/albums/xx61/MoFugger21/AdorableKitten.jpg

http://i742.photobucket.com/albums/xx61/MoFugger21/443.jpg

http://i742.photobucket.com/albums/xx61/MoFugger21/_cute_kitten.jpg

[Lefty-Canuck]

Awwww how cute are they.....

LC

[MoFugger21]

http://i742.photobucket.com/albums/xx61/MoFugger21/messyeater2.jpg

http://i742.photobucket.com/albums/xx61/MoFugger21/lgwiz02715fluffy-kittens-cute-baby-cats-poster.jpg

http://i742.photobucket.com/albums/xx61/MoFugger21/images-2.jpg

[MoFugger21]

http://i742.photobucket.com/albums/xx61/MoFugger21/14601656-adorable-small-kittens-in-wicker-basket.jpg

http://i742.photobucket.com/albums/xx61/MoFugger21/10629569-adorable-cute-kittens-on-white-background.jpg

http://i742.photobucket.com/albums/xx61/MoFugger21/4015000_f1.jpg

[MoFugger21]

http://i742.photobucket.com/albums/xx61/MoFugger21/download.jpg

http://i742.photobucket.com/albums/xx61/MoFugger21/awww_adorable_kittens_640_10.jpg

http://i742.photobucket.com/albums/xx61/MoFugger21/awww_adorable_kittens_200_100.jpg

[Vigsy]

read again, since your not the brightest vigsy, unless its hard to read cuz u've been taking facials from BGSH all day and its all up in ur eyes

EDIT: MOFUGGER21 - sweet pics man, I like them
Thank you for proving our points that your maturity level is that of a pre pubescent little boy.

[NSR Monger]

Thank you for proving our points that your maturity level is that of a pre pubescent little boy.

do you really think I care what you think about me vigsy? you are some little punk who would never talk trash to me in person

hahahaha mofugger, how long did it take you to find all those pics!!

[ZeeFishing]

60631

60632

60633

60634

[MoFugger21]

http://i742.photobucket.com/albums/xx61/MoFugger21/u69Ix9iWTn7flat1HI0q5dguo1_500.jpg

http://i742.photobucket.com/albums/xx61/MoFugger21/kitten_and_chick.jpg

http://i742.photobucket.com/albums/xx61/MoFugger21/cute-little-kitten-cat-fur-ball.jpg

[MoFugger21]

http://i742.photobucket.com/albums/xx61/MoFugger21/cute-kittens-nap-together.jpg

http://i742.photobucket.com/albums/xx61/MoFugger21/Cute-Kittens-kittens-16124041-1280-800.jpg

http://i742.photobucket.com/albums/xx61/MoFugger21/Cute-Kittens-kittens-16122540-1280-800.jpg

[MoFugger21]

http://i742.photobucket.com/albums/xx61/MoFugger21/cute-kitten-502.jpg

http://i742.photobucket.com/albums/xx61/MoFugger21/10404255.jpg

http://i742.photobucket.com/albums/xx61/MoFugger21/91159-kittens-cute.jpg

[MoFugger21]

I hereby change the theme of this thread to: ADORABLE KITTENS.


Quoted in case people missed the theme change of this thread