Estimate the weight

[Cesox]

74219 Estimate the weight of this wally

[BeeGuy]

Whoa boy.

That's a helluva walleye.

[BGSH]

8-9 pounds, good catch buddy

[BeeGuy]

13.8765lb

[The-Legend]

Like! 8 pounds

[Blastoff]

16.5 pounds, looks like a Monster

[Northern Yaker]

16.5 pounds, looks like a Monster

Can I have some of what your smoking???
9.5 lbs

[Fishfinder]

Noice Walter! 12#s 2oz.:)

[Blastoff]

Can I have some of what your smoking???
9.5 lbs

Actually having a Baileys with coffee, come on over bring your cup

[fluxcore]

I've caught a lot of big Walters is say 8lb- 9 tops by the way your holding it, it's a tank for sure

[npauls]

with or without the mud on her? :bad_boys_20:

jj

im gonna say 9-10lbs

nice eye

[fluxcore]

I'm drifting spinners with worms right now hoping for one like that lol all canopied in eatin having a cold one

[fish gunner]

Hair under 9 or a hair over. Banging eye in any water.

[CanadianBadass]

6.5 lb - 7.5 lb, I have caught tons of Eyes and that a 7 ! lol

[Winch101]

7. And change......

[Walleye101]

7.4lbs

[winger7mm]

Aint over 8 ;)

[Salavee]

Close to 30 inches so I'll go with 11.3 lbs

[Who Da Fisherman]

Won't break nine

[Cesox]

Yes sorry for the poor picture there is a lot of mud on her, as to why no weight was taken, I was in a bad spot after a long fight and more concerned about getting her back as it was hot out, please don't take any offence people who guessed 7-8lbs but I have caught lots of 7-8lb walleye that this big girl dwarfed, tried to hold fish as close to my body to give a better thought to the actual size, thank you for your estimates after talking to fish and wildlife and taking into account size of my hands and other pics I have a good idea

[BGSH]

Yes sorry for the poor picture there is a lot of mud on her, as to why no weight was taken, I was in a bad spot after a long fight and more concerned about getting her back as it was hot out, please don't take any offence people who guessed 7-8lbs but I have caught lots of 7-8lb walleye that this big girl dwarfed, tried to hold fish as close to my body to give a better thought to the actual size, thank you for your estimates after talking to fish and wildlife and taking into account size of my hands and other pics I have a good idea

On second thought probably 5-6 pounds lol ;)

[1bluZebec]

7lb's ?:)

[CanadianBadass]

Majority of us thought 6-8 ..... Therefore you go with 6-8 lbs ...... lol lol :thinking-006:

[CanadianBadass]

74219 Estimate the weight of this wally



And it is a far distance from your body, 6-9 Max

[Cesox]

After looking back at the other pics the fish was 34-36 inches

[CanadianBadass]

After looking back at the other pics the fish was 34-36 inches

Holy **** a 3 foot Walleye. That's crazy bro ! like really crazy ! :thinking-017:

[Cesox]

Holy **** a 3 foot Walleye. That's crazy bro ! like really crazy ! :thinking-017:

Pm me your email or cell and ill send you more pics

[TyreeUM]

29 inches...do I win?

[PlayDoh]

10lbs ?

[coorslightspoon]

I would guess the same . 8 to 9 lb . Hold it closer to the camera and call it ten LOL

[lotw]

if you only have a measuring tape this will get you very close, make sure to measure the girth at the widest point. This only works for walleye

length * girth * girth / 800

[FishHunterPro]

Beauty I would think 9-10lb

[FishHunterPro]

Beauty I would think 9-10lbs

[ryisnky]

Beauty fish!

[Who Da Fisherman]

74219 Estimate the weight of this wally

So it's been over a day, spill it!

[buckmaster]

74219 Estimate the weight of this wally

pushing 10lbs for sure! Awesome! Caught in the nsr?

[Cesox]

Well folks this walleye was 34-36inches based on the length to weight it's ridiculous, I won't post the weight based upon the length to weight scale, she was caught in the spring and was very fat, everything is speculation so I will call it 1 pound, thank you everyone for your insight
Tight lines everyone

[Cesox]

pushing 10lbs for sure! Awesome! Caught in the nsr?

Yes caught in the NSR

[Chris84]

So it's been over a day, spill it!

He said in a later post that he didnt weigh it.

Helluva a fish, not gonna guess because pictures dont really do very good justice all the time, all I know is its a dandy

[buckmaster]

Yes caught in the NSR

what do you think this one weighed? Caught about 5yrs ago on the nsr.

[TyreeUM]

3 foot long walleye, wow...that is a big walleye?

[pikergolf]

Well folks this walleye was 34-36inches based on the length to weight it's ridiculous, I won't post the weight based upon the length to weight scale, she was caught in the spring and was very fat, everything is speculation so I will call it 1 pound, thank you everyone for your insight
Tight lines everyone

How did you come up with the length?

[Cesox]

How did you come up with the length?

I have a picture if fish beside my rod and pic of rod with measuring tape beside it if you want the pics pm your email and ill send them, as well ill let anyone know when where and how I caught this fish, I've pulled quite a few monsters out of this spot, it is very small window that the big walleye are there and it doesn't ever disappoint, I don't believe in secret spots or secret information, anglers should help each other out, what's working where and how, the one thing that disappoints me about this forum is it often because a contest or judgment forum, a good example of good is muskies Canada, they promote conservation and educate each other, keep logs on fish caught and constantly share information, IMO that is what this forum should become but that's my own personal option
Tight lines everyone

[TyreeUM]

I have a picture if fish beside my rod and pic of rod with measuring tape beside it if you want the pics pm your email and ill send them, as well ill let anyone know when where and how I caught this fish, I've pulled quite a few monsters out of this spot, it is very small window that the big walleye are there and it doesn't ever disappoint, I don't believe in secret spots or secret information, anglers should help each other out, what's working where and how, the one thing that disappoints me about this forum is it often because a contest or judgment forum, a good example of good is muskies Canada, they promote conservation and educate each other, keep logs on fish caught and constantly share information, IMO that is what this forum should become but that's my own personal option
Tight lines everyone

well said, now post that tape measure pic so we can see who won!

[Who Da Fisherman]

74219 Estimate the weight of this wally

Well folks this walleye was 34-36inches based on the length to weight it's ridiculous, I won't post the weight based upon the length to weight scale, she was caught in the spring and was very fat, everything is speculation so I will call it 1 pound, thank you everyone for your insight
Tight lines everyone

So thanks to keep everyone guessing, like I said won't make nine then.

[pikergolf]

I have a picture if fish beside my rod and pic of rod with measuring tape beside it if you want the pics pm your email and ill send them, as well ill let anyone know when where and how I caught this fish, I've pulled quite a few monsters out of this spot, it is very small window that the big walleye are there and it doesn't ever disappoint, I don't believe in secret spots or secret information, anglers should help each other out, what's working where and how, the one thing that disappoints me about this forum is it often because a contest or judgment forum, a good example of good is muskies Canada, they promote conservation and educate each other, keep logs on fish caught and constantly share information, IMO that is what this forum should become but that's my own personal option
Tight lines everyone

Trouble with holding fish out to the camera, very hard to judge, most times it looks far larger than it is. I punched some numbers in based on hand width, I was surprised at the results, I will say it's larger than I had thought. That is not a definitive answer, just my impression. For an honest appraisal on fish it needs to be held next to your body, next to a tape, obviously the best. Based on 5'' for your gloved hand the fish is over 31", I suspect I'm being conservative on the 5" for the gloved hand which would make the fish larger, so a very good fish. Congrats.

[Who Da Fisherman]

I have a picture if fish beside my rod and pic of rod with measuring tape beside it if you want the pics pm your email and ill send them, as well ill let anyone know when where and how I caught this fish, I've pulled quite a few monsters out of this spot, it is very small window that the big walleye are there and it doesn't ever disappoint, I don't believe in secret spots or secret information, anglers should help each other out, what's working where and how, the one thing that disappoints me about this forum is it often because a contest or judgment forum, a good example of good is muskies Canada, they promote conservation and educate each other, keep logs on fish caught and constantly share information, IMO that is what this forum should become but that's my own personal option
Tight lines everyone

Thought about a long response to this but changed my mind, musky's is a whole different fishery than walleye.

[Lefty-Canuck]

I caught a 36.5 inch long and 15.5 girth walleye in Pigeon many years ago....no scale but best estimate was 13-14 plus lbs.

LC

[pikergolf]

I caught a 36.5 inch long and 15.5 girth walleye in Pigeon many years ago....no scale but best estimate was 13-14 plus lbs.

LC

36" walleye is going to a weigh a lot more than than 13-14 lbs.

[Lefty-Canuck]

36" walleye is going to a weigh a lot more than than 13-14 lbs.

Was a spawned out female....absolute hog. Ex wife and fisherman on the other bank were witnesses....no camera and no scale, fish was released.

LC

[Cesox]

Thought about a long response to this but changed my mind, musky's is a whole different fishery than walleye.

My point I think was missed, I wasn't talking just walleye I was talking angling in general, but your muskies are way different, they are way more difficult to catch, more expensive to fish for, and require a lot of time lnowledge and luck, if that group of anglers are willing to work together and share information why wouldn't anyone else? Very rare does it become a competition it is more like great fish, this is out of tournament of course. Just explaining my point I tried to make.
Tight Lines

[Fishnafterwork]

Well done bud!..... Looks bigger than the 8-9 # guys I get so I'd say just over ten ... Either way what a catch... Those biggies sure get dark from lurking in the depths :) :sHa_shakeshout:

[Cesox]

Well done bud!..... Looks bigger than the 8-9 # guys I get so I'd say just over ten ... Either way what a catch... Those biggies sure get dark from lurking in the depths :) :sHa_shakeshout:

Thanks this the main reason I posted this, probably be the last pic I post based on some of the other responses, didn't want argument or 3 post answer just a guess, send me some pics of your fish would love to see them
Tight Lines

[Kurt505]

Thanks this the main reason I posted this, probably be the last pic I post based on some of the other responses, didn't want argument or 3 post answer just a guess, send me some pics of your fish would love to see them
Tight Lines

I mean no offence, but you asked for others opinions on what they figure you fish weighed. If you don't want someone's guess, or get offended by someone saying your fish is smaller than what you believe it to be, just post a pic of a "nice" fish without asking others opinion, and I'm sure you'll get nothing but compliments. I would guess your fish at +\-28" and about 7-8lbs, that's what I see in that pic anyway. Either way it's a nice fish, congrats.

[Cesox]

I mean no offence, but you asked for others opinions on what they figure you fish weighed. If you don't want someone's guess, or get offended by someone saying your fish is smaller than what you believe it to be, just post a pic of a "nice" fish without asking others opinion, and I'm sure you'll get nothing but compliments. I would guess your fish at +\-28" and about 7-8lbs, that's what I see in that pic anyway. Either way it's a nice fish, congrats.

Options are welcome just didn't want multiple posts or arguing don't care what people's guess came in at, it's what I wanted, a guess, I'm glad the thread gained so much interest, someone could have guessed 3lb and I wouldn't be offended, also was looking for compliments on what I already know what was a good fish, but compliments appreciated, I just wanted neutral responses, that is why I said estimate the weight, not please tell me it's a good and what I wanted, thanks for the advice though and thanks for your estimate

[rielbowhunter]

here's one you guys can guess at.

[rielbowhunter]

or this one?

[Fishnafterwork]

here's one you guys can guess at.

I'll take a stab... 8.5? :) nice eye as well

[TyreeUM]

Can you post that picture with the tape?

[rielbowhunter]

I'll take a stab... 8.5? :) nice eye as well

It was caught in a sawt tourney they measured it at 75.3 cms =9.65 lbs . the other one was 6.9lbs on the scale.

[Kurt505]

Caught this one about 12-15yrs ago, 86cm (34"), no idea how much it weighed. Any guesses?

http://i881.photobucket.com/albums/ac13/Kurt505Hunter/87FFDB78-A358-46E4-8C51-F338AC235CC3-1619-000001565E1BF555.jpg

[rielbowhunter]

14 lbs

[fishinggeek]

8-9 lbs. prob 29 inch. Unless i can see a tape measure pic u got handy 😜

[Fishnafterwork]

It was caught in a sawt tourney they measured it at 75.3 cms =9.65 lbs . the other one was 6.9lbs on the scale.

Sweet .. U get in the $ with that fish then ?.... I was gonna guess 9.65 too... Haha but I wasn't too far off..:) I'm sure if it was my fish I woulda guessed 10 + ;)

[Fishnafterwork]

Awsome length Kurt!... For such a long fish where's the girth?... Sweet catch none the less!!