Pigeon or Wabamun Lake?

[Houcheimi]

Haven't tried either but looking for a close place to try out this Sunday.
Wanted your guy's opinion on which place you've been more successful In and which you prefer more for whatever reasons.

Thanks!

[carterM]

Haven't tried either but looking for a close place to try out this Sunday.
Wanted your guy's opinion on which place you've been more successful In and which you prefer more for whatever reasons.

Thanks!

Would depend on what you're looking for. For starters, Wab is c&r only so that may sway your opinion. Having said that, I've had nothing but good days out there, be it from shore or boat, fishing for pike.

Don't know about pigeon, but from what I've read in summer most guys are looking for walleye there.

[Talking moose]

If your after walleye go to pigeon. Pike go to wab

[.270fan]

If your after walleye go to pigeon. Pike go to wab

Yup... What he said ^^

You're going to be C&R at either one but you'll catch a ton

[Houcheimi]

Thank you both for your responses.
Very appreciated.

[wildwoods]

Ditto. Pigeon walleye and wab big pike
Pigeon I consider my home waters. Big bias here. Love the lake