Hot Water Tank Issues in Rental House...

[molly]

So, I did look on here for previous hot water problems and see there are some plumbers on here! Our current tenants informed us today that they have noticed the hot water running out sooner and taking longer to reheat. Naturally, I panicked and called the company we use for plumbing and heating here in Pincher Creek, and he told me the first possible culprit may be the dip tube. He then advised against trying to flush the tank as he said that does not usually do much good, if any. We bought the house in 2010 and do not know the age of the tank, although I sent a photo to the plumber of the label with the serial and model numbers on it. I imagine it is getting up there, but as finances suck right now, we are going to try and look at the cheaper options first. Thankfully, we have a new handyman down here who has proven to be very helpful to us, and he told me he has replaced a dip tube, and that it did buy a couple years on the last one he did.

So, what is your opinion on tank flushing? Worth a shot? We could do that ourselves, I guess. Should we get this guy to look at the dip tube first? I thought we should buy one of those water sensor alarms, too, just in case it decides to leak later. And if we have to buy a tank at some point, where is the best place to buy one? The plumber said $735.00 plus tax and two hours install. I saw a used one for 300. on Kijiji, haha.... :)

https://i.imgur.com/GeBWvp1.jpg?2

[JustBen]

Cheaper in the long run to replace it now. One thing you don’t want to be messing with is an old hot water heater than is having issues.

[Dewey Cox]

If the handyman will switch out the diptube for cheap, do that.
But keep in mind, if the nipple on top is rusty, and twists off instead of out, and the handyman mangles the tank trying to get it out, you'll possibly need to replace it anyway.
The quote you got on the replacement is reasonable.

[Bigwoodsman]

If you can swing it the 735.00 quote for a new tank installed is a great price. Save your self the headache and not worry about it anymore.

BW

[Sooner]

That's a good price, I paid that for mine cash and carry over 4 yrs ago and had a plumber friend install it.

Parents and Mother inlaw had theirs done last year and it was just over 1000 bucks installed for each.

I did a dip tube in my old one, got a few more years out of the old tank and it is easy to replace yourself. Neighbor had his burst, good thing he was home and heard the water running. Still had a mess to clean up.

[molly]

If you can swing it the 735.00 quote for a new tank installed is a great price. Save your self the headache and not worry about it anymore.

BW

Two hours at 85/hr to install. So, 950. with tax. :( If we have to buy one, if the dip tube thing doesn't work, we will get our handy guy to help us put it in.

[Sashi]

Don't be stupid It's $10 for a dip tube and 15 min to install.

[lakerman]

if the tube doesn't work check the ball inside the cold or hot, at the top of the tank, google it, I can't remember at the moment, pulled that out and works great.

[molly]

Don't be stupid It's $10 for a dip tube and 15 min to install.

Stupid? Thanks! Glad to know it is ten bucks, though. The plumbers said it was $40.00...

[Sashi]

Note: I didn't call you Stupid , I just said don't be. The last time I replaced a dip tube it was $8 at Rona, Anyone that is handy should be able to change it for you. There are instructions on utube.

[molly]

Note: I didn't call you Stupid , I just said don't be. The last time I replaced a dip tube it was $8 at Rona, Anyone that is handy should be able to change it for you. There are instructions on utube.

:) Thanks! Good to know.

[brendan's dad]

I just upgrade from a 40 to 50 gallon and tank, install, and new venting was $1000 all in from LPH in Leduc. Great company.

[fordtruckin]

More expensive but I’m a big fan of instant hot water heaters as they save on gas bills since it isn’t burning gas when your not drawing hot water. Plus you then have unlimited hot water. Back to the initial question, how old is the house? I’d try the cheaper fixes first knowing there’s the possibility of total replacement.

[TBark]

Did a $50 job on my tank 2 years ago, hot water is still a major improvement over what it was.
Did the dip tube, but likely I broke it off taking the old one out, so old tube is still inside. So new tube, $12.
Bought 7-8 four Ltr jugs of vinegar on sale somewhere.
I S/D the gas /burner and water, Drained the tank, in with the vinegar, and topped up til near full, leave for 5-6 hrs. Even circ it if u can with small pump with hose fittings, I used my blue bowl gold panning 12v pump. Drained and flushed clean.
Finally and might be just as important as the water side is the fire side.
Take the tank top flu off, cover the burner with a pc of paper or cardboard.
Wire brush the tank flu area as far down as you can reach.
Vacuumed out the bottom area, you should see lots of crap.

This has saved me a few years for now, but ya, I will need a new tank in time.

TBark

[rjlester]

Hot water tank in my house is ten years old. It is a Canadian made unit that has been working great, first issue was last week, we had no hot water. Changed the thermocouple and has been good since. Still heats up like day one.

Don't mind a ten buck fix in ten years. Hope you get yours fixed cheap or find a good deal on a new one.

[yz295]

HWTs should be flushed once a year at the very least. Is it making any banging noises as it heats? Your dip tube will be disintegrated and floating around in the tank. Changing it will definitely help with the lack of hot water. You'll want to check the colour of the flame as well and make sure its a nice blue colour. As for the flush, it is likely you will see a minor leak on the bottom of the tank if a proper flush is done but it should seal up within 30 mins of running. I see it on units all the time.

What you are experiencing is lack of maintenance and could be a combination of a few things. Any decent handyman will be able to look at it and determine best next steps. If you plan on doing some work to your existing unit change your relief valve while you're at it. HWTs that aren't operating properly are bombs! Like furnaces, I keep spare parts in my basement to fix any issue I could have. Best to be prepared.

[250mark1]

Your current tank was made in 2004

[molly]

HWTs should be flushed once a year at the very least. Is it making any banging noises as it heats? Your dip tube will be disintegrated and floating around in the tank. Changing it will definitely help with the lack of hot water. You'll want to check the colour of the flame as well and make sure its a nice blue colour. As for the flush, it is likely you will see a minor leak on the bottom of the tank if a proper flush is done but it should seal up within 30 mins of running. I see it on units all the time.

What you are experiencing is lack of maintenance and could be a combination of a few things. Any decent handyman will be able to look at it and determine best next steps. If you plan on doing some work to your existing unit change your relief valve while you're at it. HWTs that aren't operating properly are bombs! Like furnaces, I keep spare parts in my basement to fix any issue I could have. Best to be prepared.

No banging noises. It had its annual service check in December. Did not know about tank flushing until I read about it this week, and too bad the plumbers never mentioned it. :)
We'll be replacing the dip tube next week after I find one. I guess they are not all the same so don't want to buy one and it is too short!

Your current tank was made in 2004

Yes. I finally figured that out! Hopefully this fix will buy us some time as our finances suck at the moment. Thanks!

[Dewey Cox]

. As for the flush, it is likely you will see a minor leak on the bottom of the tank if a proper flush is done but it should seal up within 30 mins of running. I see it on units all the time.
.

Could you explain this a little more?
Are you saying the tank starts leaking all the time, and magically heals itself? Or are you just getting a drip onto the burner?

[Sundancefisher]

Your current tank was made in 2004

14 years. Pretty good.

Any money you put into repairs now will just be added onto the cost of a new one.

I find when they start to go...they are going.

[CaberTosser]

Could you explain this a little more?
Are you saying the tank starts leaking all the time, and magically heals itself? Or are you just getting a drip onto the burner?

He’s probably mistaking condensation dripping from the flue of a tank of ice cold water being heated as a ‘leak’. It would be cold after flushing it out, but then you already know that.

As for the OP, avoid used heaters on Kijiji, it’s a bit late to discover they leak after you’ve had it installed. If they don’t leak you also don’t know how it’s been handled since removal, it’s a real gamble to put that type of thing in only to have to replace it in 6-18 months. It’s a false economy.

[Passthru]

Dip tube is easy to replace. Did mine a couple years ago. If it needs replacing you will see an instant difference. This is a very common and inexpensive fix for ageing water heaters.

[molly]

As for the OP, avoid used heaters on Kijiji, it’s a bit late to discover they leak after you’ve had it installed. If they don’t leak you also don’t know how it’s been handled since removal, it’s a real gamble to put that type of thing in only to have to replace it in 6-18 months. It’s a false economy.

Thanks, Caber. I was kinda kidding about that, as you are right - who knows what the history is of a used tank?

Will do the dip tube first and see what happens. :)

[SammyS778]

We have the same issue. The water in the house takes what seems like a really long time to get from cold to hot. Especially in the bathroom that is farthest from the hot water heater. Also, once the water does warm up and is then turned off it is cold again in minutes and you have to wait for it to warm back up. Any plumber (https://startdrain.ca/) here to help?

[yz295]

Could you explain this a little more?
Are you saying the tank starts leaking all the time, and magically heals itself? Or are you just getting a drip onto the burner?


Tank will drip a small amount of water on the burners and will fill the hole with sediment within 30 mins or so after running. Some of the time its condensation. Sometimes its little pin hole leaks.

[CaberTosser]

Tank will drip a small amount of water on the burners and will fill the hole with sediment within 30 mins or so after running. Some of the time its condensation. Sometimes its little pin hole leaks.

It’s always condensation. If it’s a leak it’s extraordinarily rare for it to get perfectly plugged by scale, then it’s buh-bye time for that tank.

FYI: Dewey and myself are both journeyman plumbers, so understand that we both know what we’re talking about on this subject. He and I were both wondering what you were talking about and now that you’ve clarified it’s quite apparent that you’re mistaken regarding pinhole leaks that ‘fix themselves’. I’m
Not sure of Dewey’s time in the trade but I’m at 31 years full time+ personally.

[Dewey Cox]

I've only been in the trade half as long as Caber, but I did stay at a holiday inn recently.

[Jamie]

I've only been in the trade half as long as Caber, but I did stay at a holiday inn recently.

Shhhhh. Don't remind Caber he is really old...


As for the Hot water tank. You are not there as a owner to check on it everyday. Put in a new one. Raise the rent by a few bucks a month. (They won't move out) and keep going.

[tri777]

We have the same issue. The water in the house takes what seems like a really long time to get from cold to hot. Especially in the bathroom that is farthest from the hot water heater. Also, once the water does warm up and is then turned off it is cold again in minutes and you have to wait for it to warm back up. Any plumber (https://startdrain.ca/) here to help?
If your heater is electric, i would say your top element is fried.

[CaberTosser]

Shhhhh. Don't remind Caber he is really old...


Hey, I resemble that remark!

I ain't even 50 yet, I just started in the trade early working for my Pop :). That being said, I'm in the zone I can count down the months until then by removing my socks.

[brslk]

Frankly I'm disappointed that no one has said "why do you need to heat hot water" or some such thing.

Like how there always has to be that one guy that points out that it's "concrete" and not "cement".

Carry on.

[Okotok]

Frankly I'm disappointed that no one has said "why do you need to heat hot water" or some such thing.

Like how there always has to be that one guy that points out that it's "concrete" and not "cement".

Carry on.

I thought it but didn't say it as I'm sure many did. You win. :)

[58thecat]

Stupid? Thanks! Glad to know it is ten bucks, though. The plumbers said it was $40.00...

one word youtube.......saved me thousands over the years....

[molly]

It was the dip tube. Cost $16 at Home Hardware and the handy man guy put it in after we drained the tank. So it cost us about 66.00 and he said he can get us a new heater at a discount down the road should we need one. So we are happy with that.
Thanks everyone. :)

[crazyperch]

It was the dip tube. Cost $16 at Home Hardware and the handy man guy put it in after we drained the tank. So it cost us about 66.00 and he said he can get us a new heater at a discount down the road should we need one. So we are happy with that.
Thanks everyone. :)

Glad it was an easy fix for you Molly.
I wonted to change my Dip tube on my hot water tank this past weekend.
disconnected everything, went to pull the dip tube and well it wasn't attached anymore.

Went from a $15 job to a $630 (Did the job myself) new hot water tank install.

[RapStaff]

With the new copper pipe options out there now adays it would be super simple to buy a tank and put it in yourself. Shark bite fittings are pretty slick. I had to replace my tank a couple years ago. Had my cousin coming by to help me. He bailed on me and left me in a huge pickle as i had already tore out the old tank. A quick trip to home depot and i had everything i needed to install without soldering in the pipe. You tube videos help out as well. Alot of the time ive managed to find the exact model of what im trying to fix and someone has posted up a video on how they did it. 😀
Hope you get it sorted out.

[tri777]

Shark bite fittings are pretty slick. I had to replace my tank a couple years ago. . . A quick trip to home depot and i had everything i needed to install without soldering in the pipe. .

Caber is not going to like hearing about those shark bites
being a permanent fix for your heater though.

[crazyperch]

Caber is not going to like hearing about those shark bites
being a permanent fix for your heater though.

lol x2