Chickakoo lake vs Sauer lake
 

Why does it seem that the fish are bigger in Sauer lake. I went there today and caught an 11incher. The ones in Chickakoo were very small like 6 or 7 inches.

Sauer was stocked with 7 - 8 inchers in 2009, 2010 & 2011

Chickakoo was stocked with 7 - 8 inchers in 2009 & 2011 but nothing in 2010

The bigger one in Sauer probably made it through from last year but since Chickakoo was not stocked last year and '09 was 2 years ago, you are catching this year's stock which hasn't even been in there a month yet in Chickakoo.