Should trophy fish be easy or difficult to catch?
Quick poll to see what people think - Do you like the idea of having large/trophy fish more readily available and easy to catch, or should they be more difficult and rare?
Add any extra thoughts in the comments section. |
Quote:
Theoretically, even though there might be more large fish in a waterbody, they should be more challenging to catch. Look at the Bow river for example: more large fish per km than most rivers in the world; however, how many fishermen (even veteran ones) have left the Bow scratching their heads and soothing their egos on many days. Of course, there are also the days that you can do no wrong, which are the ones that keep us coming back. I think there are some people that think that by making stricter regs, and thus more large fish, that somehow the fish are going to be easy to catch. I don't think that's the case. They get smart after getting stung a couple of times. The challenge is in knowing there is a good possibility of catching a big fish and then trying to get it to bite. I'd much rather fish all day for the chance of a big fish than catch a bunch of 12" stockers. And of course there needs to be put and take fisheries as well where you can chuck powerbait all day with your kids and keep a bucket-full of 12" stockers. I'm just saying that my preference is for fishing places where you have the chance to catch bigger fish. Cheers. |
I can't see why it would be a bad thing to have more big fish in our local waters.
|
I think big fish should be available for everyone without to much difficulty.
|
Of course I want to catch more trophy fish more easily.
Anyone who says differently is not telling the truth. But if they were easily got would they really be trophies? |
50/50
not so easy that they arnt a trophy anymore because they are cuaght so ofetn but a little more frequently caught:fighting0030:
|
if it was easy they wont be trophy anymore. They are only trophies because they are rare and difficult to catch.
|
Should be hard to catch or they wouldn't be called trophy's
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
http://www.outdoorsmenforum.ca/showthread.php?t=123352 |
All fisheries in Ab should be managed to be healthy fisheries. Large fish are nothing more than a bi product of proper management. Wether that makes large fish more accessible to anglers or not is moot point.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
I've fished some outstanding fisheries outside of Alberta, and I would imagine some of our lakes could get close to their quality with the proper management. For example, Great Slave Lake in the NWT has pike that regularly get up to 20 lbs and you can sometimes catch numerous fish close to that size in a day, but the bigger fish are rare, so the real big fish are still rare trophies, but there are many large fish to catch. I also once fished Jurassic Lake in Argentina, it is non-stop fishing for rainbows averaging 10 lbs, but 20 lb fish were rare and you had to put in a lot of effort to catch one that size. I think some people just accept what we have as good enough and don't think about how much potential some of our lakes have. I bet a lot of people's ideas of what a trophy trout or pike is wouldn't actually be super large. How commonly do you hear of a 10 lb rainbow being caught in Alberta that wasn't a brood stock fish? |
RE:
Quote:
And of course the trophys should be a fight to get , gotta work harder to catch something worth while! |
Quote:
Set up other lakes with high limits and no size restrictions for those to fill their freezers and for those that think it should be a challenge to catch a trophy. Win win win. (or lose depending on the lake:fighting0030:) As I said on the other thread, why not make something world class. For those that get bored with catching too many 20lbers, I am sure there are other lakes they can fish. It is about creating an enviroment that can reach its potential not just about making it easy. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
I would like to see all of alberta go on 100% catch and release for a few years (3-5??).
It would allow the fish to get big and spawn and get the numbers back where they should be naturally. I couldn't care less if we went catch and release for 10 years.. It would weed out the real outdoorsman from the weekend bucket fillers. |
A trophy is only a trophy because of the rarity/difficulty of the task.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
imagine all those fished out lakes in AB bounce back to be like a fly in like in northern sask or manitoba. Its possible, we just need it managed and in my opinion 100% catch and release for a few years followed be STRICT limits for many years afterwards.. I ask you, would you trade the aspect of keeping fish in exchange to see all our lakes back to the way nature made them? I would. |
southern BC's large lakes are full of trophy rainbow, their numbers are abundant however they are very tough to catch.
far too many in our province think killing the big ones is a right not a privilege.world class waters get that way when the general public in that area allows the the fish to live long happy lives something this part of the world is short on. |
I fish for meat . the bigger the better !
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
trophy fish
If they were easy, they would not be trophy??
|
You live in Canada, trophy fish ARE easy to catch...why do you think so many people pay thousands of dollars to come up here and fish? If they were any easier to catch they would just be called "fish"...
|
All times are GMT -6. The time now is 05:34 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.5
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.