I would take MacInnis over Iggy.
Cup Winner
Conn Smythe
Norris Trophy
Hardest shot in the NHL and a righty.
In 1990/91 he had 103 pts in 78 games which is more than Iggy ever had in a single season and Iggy started in the NHL only 5 years later so that is not really an era issue.
In 20 season MacInnis had 1270 points. In 21 seasons Iggy had 1300 points.
Also he is an Eastern boy which earns him a couple extra points
|