I think you would be okay with either. If you're lucky and they group the same maybe just run both. The nice thing about the mechanical is the larger cutting diameter. In my opinion the more cutting you can do the better. If an elk is hit forward in the shoulder it won't matter what you are shooting for heads it wont die. If you hit an elk a little back you might be thankful for a bigger cut. Id say just shoot whatever head you are most comfortable. If you cant have confidence in the penetration of the reapers don't use them. I would think you will be most successful and shoot the best with whatever you have the most confidence in.
-Best of luck.
|