View Single Post
  #69  
Old 09-28-2011, 11:37 AM
Christofficer's Avatar
Christofficer Christofficer is offline
 
Join Date: Jul 2010
Location: Calgary
Posts: 384
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Sundancefisher View Post
There is no need to kill and remove any fish species unless in a study area.

Quirk Creek is removing brook trout to protect native cutts and bulls.

Removing suckers and mountain whitefish does nothing to benefit the health of a stream. For years...even the mentality in F&W was to remove "undesireable" fish such as mountain whitefish. However as time passes we in the fishing interest group realized that the whitefish fry and young of the year are an important food for larger bulls, cutts and rainbows.

The same applies to suckers. Nature actually staggers spawning so that the predators have a great food source to grow on.

In lakes...sucker fry feed the next crop of pike and walleye.

In rivers...whitefish and sucker fry also benefit the predators.

I never kill fish needlessly unless I am eating them.

Cheers

Sun
Yeah, that sums up my opinion on the subject.

Not sure why anyone would do that to a mountain whitefish. They're annoying to catch when you're targeting other fish I suppose, but correct me if I'm wrong, never heard of whitefish over populating and stunting or killing off other fish.
Reply With Quote