You need to change your name to FishingDave if you want us to take you seriously
Dave, not seeing that anyone here is saying that 5 is too much. Simply that have a 5 take lake but also offer a choice of quality fisheries that are managed differently (low or no limits, low stocking, aeration, etc.). So put simply back, would you like a choice of both kinds of fisheries in Alberta?
P.S. I can tell you that Muir lake up near Deadmonton has made a huge difference to a lot of anglers that were looking for another choice of quality.