Fisherpotch,
We stayed at Majestic Colonial. This resort was just beautiful and the food was very good too. The staff was all very friendly and I would definitely stay there again!
The fishing was booked through the tour guys at the hotel and I think it was called Marlin sportfishing.
I did some looking online (goolge fishing Punta Cana) before we went and after we got home and I think that all the companies for fishing in Punta Cana are the same one--the pictures are all of the same company.
Now that being said, I don't know if we would go with them again or not for a couple of reasons.
1. They got us to their ''headquarters'' and they had a gift shop there that they dragged you into first for the "hard sell"
2. The day we went was extremely windy and rainy. Now don't get me wrong I can fish in wind and rain, but this was very bad--we had 15 foot seas--not swells but waves and you could not stand on the boat without hanging on to something. The guide almost went over the back of the boat once except, he grabbed a rod holder and held on. The guy at the hotel told us after, that all the tours had been cancelled for the next two days.
3. We actually had to ask for life jackets and I'm really not sure about the safety equipment on the boat--the guide didn't wear a life jacket.
4. You guys can ''go'' over the side. For us gals, I would have been better off with an ice cream pail.