Huge Mule deer-score anyone ?

[Acesneights]

Originally Posted by H380

Ya right , that's why you see so many record books that list "ONLY " gross scores . Guess all us so called "DORKS " will just have to stick with the B&C and P&Y method of scoring .. That is until one of you " GROSS" guys comes out with your own book .. The deer in question is a beauty regardless of score , kinda like sheephunter said .

Just sayin that there are many of old guys who have shot giant animals and none of them would for one enter those animals in any record book which is a shame to me but they dont agree in being in some ****ing contest.Some dog is probably chewing on the antlers right now and if I asked them how big they think that mule is they would say big and a shooter.But I'm sure that ww2269 was asking gross like most people so why did anyone bring up net was all I was getting at.You guys must hate Big Buck cause most of the deer Garry puts in there only have a gross score.One of my whitetails grosses 184 and nets 137 and the net score doesn't do the deer justice so really gross gives you a very good realistic number to go by.Don't insult me with sci.

Originally Posted by bdarling

You guys must hate Big Buck cause most of the deer Garry puts in there only have a gross score..

I don't hate anything I just find it amusing that most people utilize a system based on symetry to talk about deer scores and then forget the symetry part. It doesn't matter to me what guys use.....I just find it amusing. I also find it funny that the guys that use the system the way it was designed get mocked.

[Acesneights]

Better described as a 184" whitetail or a 137"

[H380]

Originally Posted by bdarling

Just sayin that there are many of old guys who have shot giant animals and none of them would for one enter those animals in any record book which is a shame to me but they dont agree in being in some ****ing contest.Some dog is probably chewing on the antlers right now and if I asked them how big they think that mule is they would say big and a shooter.But I'm sure that ww2269 was asking gross like most people so why did anyone bring up net was all I was getting at.You guys must hate Big Buck cause most of the deer Garry puts in there only have a gross score.One of my whitetails grosses 184 and nets 137 and the net score doesn't do the deer justice so really gross gives you a very good realistic number to go by.Don't insult me with sci.

Wasn't intending on throwing out an insult and I hope none was taken .. It's just a matter of how things get compared . A 184gross whitetail is impressive indeed , just like the muley shown and I'd be happy with either . I don't hate Bigbuck magazine because of the gross scores , I hate it cause I'm not sitting behind one of those monsters .. lol .

Originally Posted by bdarling

Better described as a 184" whitetail or a 137"

Under B&C.....137. I'd call it a great buck personally.

[Acesneights]

Originally Posted by sheephunter

I don't hate anything I just find it amusing that most people utilize a system based on symetry to talk about deer scores and then forget the symetry part. It doesn't matter to me what guys use.....I just find it amusing. I also find it funny that the guys that use the system the way it was designed get mocked.

I just find it fun to debate and I didnt mean to mock you more or less wondering why you didnt throw in a score.Because he was asking for a gross score it even said what he was looking for in the header so why no guessand still no guess sheephunter.Thats all take care happy new year

Originally Posted by bdarling

I just find it fun to debate and I didnt mean to mock you more or less wondering why you didnt throw in a score.Because he was asking for a gross score it even said what he was looking for in the header so why no guessand still no guess sheephunter.Thats all take care happy new year

I can't add up all those deductions in my mind

Happy new year to you as well!

[NIKON]

I use 155-160 gross as a bench mark for a whitetail rifle kill........ For me a 160 and larger I take notice... lol... A 140 gross or larger whitetail with a bow is a fine specimen....... Don't flame me but that's what i call a good buck, But any buck with a bow is a trophy
Everyone has a different bench mark depending on your hunting area and trophy quality
Nikon

[NIKON]

For mulies I set a bench mark on 175-180 or larger as a good buck with a rifle...... Get a 170 with a bow is a beauty....... A mule in the 200 is quite an accomplishment, been so close.....lol... Of course talking gross

Nikon

[Justin.C]

Hey guys ........MULEDEER SCORE GUESSING THREAD.......

[NIKON]

Originally Posted by Justin.C

Hey guys ........MULEDEER SCORE GUESSING THREAD.......

Justin

That's callin the kettle black isn't it?...... remember the big mulie thread you started?........
Just sayin

Nikon

[Justin.C]

Originally Posted by NIKON

Justin

That's callin the kettle black isn't it?...... remember the big mulie thread you started?........
Just sayin

Nikon

Hey I responded to a comment that was faulse in my own thread.... Then hell broke loose.. After I posted a picture of a Monster nontypical it became a very quite thread.... who cares about whitetails in a muledeer thread.... just sayin

[NIKON]

3 pages worth of posts........ just sayin

Nikon

[ishootbambi]

Originally Posted by Justin.C

who cares about whitetails in a muledeer thread.... just sayin

sorry.....would 179 and change better describe this.....or 138?



i stand behind what i said. a gross score describes the animal better then a net score ever could. net only matters if you care about a book somewhere....or maybe a big buck contest. and the only guys who would try to assign a net score while field judging are dorks.

sorry....i might not have made it clear enough..... MEGA DORKS!!!!!!

oh...gotta make it PC, so lol and and

[Justin.C]

Originally Posted by ishootbambi

sorry.....would 179 and change better describe this.....or 138?



i stand behind what i said. a gross score describes the animal better then a net score ever could. net only matters if you care about a book somewhere....or maybe a big buck contest. and the only guys who would try to assign a net score while field judging are dorks.

sorry....i might not have made it clear enough..... MEGA DORKS!!!!!!

oh...gotta make it PC, so lol and and

Dale your original post was correct. So was this one I just see all the wts coming in to buddies muledeer thread. That is all. Not knocking anybody. I just figured to keep it on track. But thanks for posting a 240" muledeer here other than that wt that scores the same.

[ishootbambi]

aw c'mon....he is 260 easy....and the op is about 290 using some guys methods.