Standard red and white or five of diamonds spoons, cranks (shallow and poppers) in frog, perch or firetiger patterns have always produced very well out of the Carburn ponds, particularly the northernmost one.
I was at Carburn last week (for about an hour) only had one follow up and I was using a red and yellow 5 of diamonds. There where a few other people fishing and I did not see any one catch anything.