Im not helping you because of your views on handguns.
Keeping that in mind....
I rarely use Raps, not for any reason....I just have better luck and better action on other baits.
My go-to bait for pike is a Cotten Cordell Ripplin Redfin. You can get these things anywhere they are fairly cheap (shows on the finish) but they produce.
My second bait that I would suggest to anyone, 3X Strike King series plastics, mainly in the minnow/slug pattern. Anyone that uses these things for pike knows they are just unbeatable when they are tight lipped.
I use those 2 baits in different colours probably 75% of the time.
Other baits Id suggest are....
Mepps Maribou's, hands down one of the best large inline spinner.
Heddons Zara Spook, need a fairly flexible rod to get a great action out of them but when the wolves are feeding ontop, cant beat em. If you dont know how to walk the dog, youll figure it out in a day.
I prefer Williams Wabblers over any 5 of diamonds. Dont get me wrong 5oD's are great for trolling but for casting, Wabblers get my vote. Not only can you work these things slow but they are a fantastic bait to roll down a set of rapids...Pickeral love them aswell.
Hope that helps ya out.