ID this Fish: UPDATED...Salmo....

[BeeGuy]

if so keep it to yourself.

LB

[chubbdarter]

Originally Posted by BeeGuy

something about a dirty bird?

no......but some guys got some explaining to do

[Lefty-Canuck]

Originally Posted by chubbdarter

no......but some guys fish in womens underhosen like I do

....aww that makes sense to me now...

LC

[TreeGuy]

Beeguy, I just want to appologize for the derail, and now again continuing it. I will not be called a liar or a criminal.......

Originally Posted by flyfishing only 902

yes the get retarded huge and have been caught in the 100 pound range in commercial nets. but the largest one ever landed in canada was on a quebec river in 1939 in quebec and measured 49 3/4 inches and had a girth of 30 1/8 inch.
what river did you catch it in?

Originally Posted by flyfishing only 902

i grew up fishing the margaree which is known world wide for its big fish and only on one occasion in 15 years ever saw a fish even close to 50 inches. oh and to further back up my calling bull**** on you is the fact that it is illegal to intentionally fish for them. but hey thanks for admitting you broke the law on a public forum.

Originally Posted by flyfishing only 902

all 3 said it was by far the biggest salmon they had ever seen. and it was estimated at 50'- 52' inches.
.

So it would appear that the only thing crappier than you attitude are your reading comprehension skills.

Using your own words, you admit that Atlantics have been caught over 100# and in the 50"+ range. Yet I post I caught one that was 54" and I'm a liar and a criminal? What's that make the L&F officer standing beside me then?

Reread my post pal before shooting your big yap off ok?

Again, BG, sorry for the hijack bud.

Originally Posted by TreeGuy

It took a 'Red Devil' spoon loaded up with night crawlers, with 10# test on spinning gear. There wasn't much left of the old girl and it only took about less than 10 minutes to reel her in. (She was well under 20#s we figured)


I measured the mark later at 54", but you must allow a +/- 2" margin of error to be fair, no?

[chubbdarter]

Tree...no highjack the contest/poll is over

i was going to respond but figured you could explain it better...

p.s. thanks again my tree is almost all better

[Lefty-Canuck]

^^^^^
I was wondering about that too....how are you targeting a specific species with a red devil and a glob of night crawlers? Is that salmon kryptonite or something? I would think more along the lines of sucker or sturgeon with that contraption on the end of my line

LC

[BeeGuy]

Never take anything on the internet too seriously. If you do, you've already lost.

[FisherGirl84]

Originally Posted by Alberta Bigbore

I voted Largemouth Bass

hahaha that was great!

[flyfishing only 902]

Originally Posted by TreeGuy

Beeguy, I just want to appologize for the derail, and now again continuing it. I will not be called a liar or a criminal.......









So it would appear that the only thing crappier than you attitude are your reading comprehension skills.

Using your own words, you admit that Atlantics have been caught over 100# and in the 50"+ range. Yet I post I caught one that was 54" and I'm a liar and a criminal? What's that make the L&F officer standing beside me then?

Reread my post pal before shooting your big yap off ok?

Again, BG, sorry for the hijack bud.

they have been caught that big in commercial nets . and yes you are right i AM calling you a LIAR and a CRIMINAL and if there was an officer standing there while you and however many other fished for slinks on PURPOSE where they gather then he obviously has no idea what he is doing. again this is just another reason im calling you a LIAR.
YOU DID NOT CATCH A 54" SALMON and fishing for slinks is illegal in the province of nova scotia.
maybe next time try choosing a better subject to talk BS about.


and i have read your post many times and based on what i know to be FACTS its nothing more then a fish tale.

[TyreeUM]

Originally Posted by flyfishing only 902

they have been caught that big in commercial nets . and yes you are right i AM calling you a LIAR and a CRIMINAL and if there was an officer standing there while you and however many other fished for slinks on PURPOSE where they gather then he obviously has no idea what he is doing. again this is just another reason im calling you a LIAR.
YOU DID NOT CATCH A 54" SALMON and fishing for slinks is illegal in the province of nova scotia.
maybe next time try choosing a better subject to talk BS about.


and i have read your post many times and based on what i know to be FACTS its nothing more then a fish tale.

if I said I caught a 41lb rainbow trout I am quite sure 99% of the population would call me a liar as well....give it a rest

[admin]

This thread is done... closed.