Go Back   Alberta Outdoorsmen Forum > Main Category > Hunting Discussion

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #31  
Old 03-17-2019, 09:48 PM
bergman bergman is offline
 
Join Date: Aug 2011
Posts: 466
Default The Final Word

Quote:
Originally Posted by bdub View Post
Awesome info, thanks. How much fuel are you budgeting per day?
Hey bdub, I just went over my notes/log book from that trip and the number we used was actually 100ml per person per day, which was the amount that was way too much, especially since we had a group of 5 on that trip. Half that would be plenty for me (50ml per person per day) even leaving a good margin of error, and this is backed up by the number crunching I have done on fuel use today.

Argument 1:

Here’s one way of looking at fuel-stove combo weights, straight from the web.

A 212 gram propane cartridge contains 11 grams of fuel and claims to boil 16 litres of water (4 days worth). The stove weighs about 73 grams. The empty cartridge weighs about 100 grams.

Stove-fuel combo for 4-5 days is about 290 grams. Add another day and you carry another 100 grams of cartridge, which pretty much makes up for the full weight of a Whisperlite (200 grams) and a 375ml fuel bottle (79 grams). At 4-5 days the weight cost of each type of stove is the same.

Argument 2:

Long story short, over a longer trip a white gas stove needs less fuel bottles than iso-propane stoves and their bottles are lighter. This weight savings more than makes up for the extra weight of the white gas stove.

So:
It’s not just about the volume of fuel – the main differences between white gas, isobutene/propane & methanol is the energy density of the fuel, and regular mass-volume (how much mass of the fuel can fit in a specific container).

Propane and white gas have similar energy densities (White Gas is 44.6 MJ/kg, propane is 46.4 MJ/kg) but look at the volume a same mass of fuel would take – A kg of white gas fits in about 1.4 litres of space, a kg of liquid propane fits in about 2 litres of space, so with similar amounts of fuel propane will require larger canisters or a greater number of smaller canisters. It also requires sturdier canisters since it is under pressure.

Here is a scenario:

Assume (for comparisons) that we want to boil 3 litres of water per day. The water is ice cold (zero degrees) and we want to boil it at sea level, so boiling temp is 100 degrees. It takes 4200 joules to raise the temperature of one litre of water one degree Celsius, and 420,000 joules to raise the temperature of one litre of water from 0 to 100 degrees.

We will also assume no heat loss to wind, etc. but will use the net-value of energy in fuels to account for heating the combustion gases & water vapour produced from burning fuels to get as accurate fuel usage as possible.

So, per day we need 1,260,000 joules or 1.26 mega-joules (MJ) of heat.
From there it’s pretty easy to calculate how much of each fuel you require per day, and how many containers you need to carry it. I will let you do that part.

I have included two pictures of the excel sheet I did up. The first is a bare bones example using the above scenario, using 1.26 MJ of heat per day. The second is a more “Realistic Use” scenario, where I double the heat use per day to account for a brew at night, heat loss during transfer, and general entropy.

Conclusion:
You can see on the “Realistic Use” table, that up to day 4-5 both Propane and White Gas are within 50 grams of each other, but after that White Gas takes off as the clear leader. Notably at day 9-10 and again at 14-15, a Propane stove with fuel will weigh a full pound more than its White Gas alternative. Adding more people (extra fuel requirements) or more days will increase the lead that White Gas has over Propane.

Also, Methanol Stoves are super light for an overnight or a day trip, but due to its very low energy density (net caloric value) of 19.9MJ/kg Methanol simply can’t keep up. Ethanol is similar at 26.7MJ/kg, which is why it is such a poor fuel for vehicles, and at about half the density of gasoline a tank of ethanol will take you half as far as a tank of gas.

The one thing I did not include is data on heat transfer, which is where the JetBoil might improve things for the Propane stove fans.

Remember, too, that this is just weight considerations, and WEIGHT IS NOT THE MOST IMPORTANT QUALITY. RELIABILITY MATTERS.
Bringing a heavy stove that is reliable is way better than carrying a broken stove that doesn’t work and is just dead weight.


If anyone wants the excel file to play with send me a pm and an email address I can send it to.
If anyone wants to use this data/ write up in some other format, send me a pm as well.
Cheers,
E. B.

References:
All fuel data is taken from https://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/f...ues-d_169.html
For Propane I used measurements from MSR IsoPro cartridges, which come in 110 gram, 227 gram and 450 gram bottles, which weigh a total 212g, 377g, & 650g respectively (cartridge plus fuel).
For white gas I used the MSR Whisperlite Fuel Bottles, which come in 375 ml (holds 325ml fuel, weighs 45 grams), 650ml (holds 590ml fuel, weighs 114g) and 975ml (holds 880ml fuel, weighs 158 grams)
For Methanol I take the fuel in an empty soda bottle, or an empty Sriracha bottle with a screw top lid for fine pouring (the best).
Attached Images
File Type: jpg Bare Bones Stove-Fuel Comparison.jpg (63.6 KB, 20 views)
File Type: jpg Realistic Use Stove-Fuel Comparison.jpg (62.0 KB, 20 views)
__________________
pop pop POP
Reply With Quote
  #32  
Old 03-17-2019, 10:44 PM
bdub's Avatar
bdub bdub is offline
 
Join Date: Jun 2011
Posts: 3,713
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by bergman View Post
Hey bdub, I just went over my notes/log book from that trip and the number we used was actually 100ml per person per day, which was the amount that was way too much, especially since we had a group of 5 on that trip. Half that would be plenty for me (50ml per person per day) even leaving a good margin of error, and this is backed up by the number crunching I have done on fuel use today.

That's great info. Thanks for spending some time and sharing that.
It would be interesting to compare the energy transfer between the Jetboil setup and the Whisperlite using the wind screen.
__________________
There are some who can live without wild things, and some who cannot. Aldo Leopold
Reply With Quote
  #33  
Old 03-18-2019, 08:52 AM
Puma's Avatar
Puma Puma is offline
 
Join Date: May 2007
Location: WMU 214
Posts: 1,816
Default Stoves

Quote:
Originally Posted by calgarychef View Post
I used to love my coleman single burner and it’s still going strong after um... 35 years? I surprised Coleman didn’t use that platform with a separate pressurized bottle like MSR did. The Coleman burns hot and simmers well, it’s easy (ish) on gas, just a fantastic stove if it didn’t have that heavy tank.
Coleman 502 single burner, an Optimus Hunter 8 clam pack and a Optimus #80. All naptha fueled. Been making coffee and meals on these for 35 + years and they still work like new and heat up like no other stoves. Ice fishing, extended paddling trips, horse packing in the mountains or just day hunts, never failed me. A stove with a full tank and a couple of those skinny Primus fuel bottles and I'm good for a week. Tank on # 8 /80 lasts 1.5 hours and boils a quart of water in under 4 minutes.

Last edited by Puma; 03-18-2019 at 09:04 AM.
Reply With Quote
  #34  
Old 03-18-2019, 10:15 PM
jungleboy's Avatar
jungleboy jungleboy is offline
Moderator
 
Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: Stony Plain
Posts: 6,568
Default

Nobody mentions the twig stoves as an alternative. Lite weight ,some versions fold flat so very little room taken up in the pack and you don't have to drag fuel along with you. If you are semi competent with a pair of snips and a can opener you can even make your own .
Reply With Quote
  #35  
Old 03-18-2019, 10:27 PM
obsessed1 obsessed1 is online now
 
Join Date: Jan 2013
Posts: 2,919
Default

I have a whisper light and a pocket rocket. Neither get used as much as my foldable twig stove. Packs light and never ran out of fuel yet.
Reply With Quote
  #36  
Old 03-19-2019, 08:51 AM
ghostguy6's Avatar
ghostguy6 ghostguy6 is offline
 
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: edmonton
Posts: 3,116
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by jungleboy View Post
Nobody mentions the twig stoves as an alternative. Lite weight ,some versions fold flat so very little room taken up in the pack and you don't have to drag fuel along with you. If you are semi competent with a pair of snips and a can opener you can even make your own .
But also prohibited if there is a fire ban. Im also told they are not allowed in national parks and provincial campgrounds. Can anyone confirm this? I do know they can not be used in Provincial Rec areas unless you place them in a designated fire pit.
__________________
" Everything in life that I enjoy is either illegal, immoral, fattening or causes cancer!"

"The problem was this little thing called the government and laws."
Reply With Quote
  #37  
Old 03-19-2019, 12:34 PM
bdub's Avatar
bdub bdub is offline
 
Join Date: Jun 2011
Posts: 3,713
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by obsessed1 View Post
I have a whisper light and a pocket rocket. Neither get used as much as my foldable twig stove. Packs light and never ran out of fuel yet.
Why not just build little fire? Not sure what the advantage of the twig stove would be. Other than in the parks where building a little stick fire in some rocks would be frowned upon I suppose.
__________________
There are some who can live without wild things, and some who cannot. Aldo Leopold
Reply With Quote
  #38  
Old 03-31-2019, 03:08 PM
nimrod's Avatar
nimrod nimrod is offline
 
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: Alberta for the most part
Posts: 2,810
Default

I have a Hot Ash mini stove titanium, and a jet boil titanium and a whisper international stove, ready for anything in the back country
Reply With Quote
  #39  
Old 04-01-2019, 06:22 AM
Ronaround Ronaround is offline
 
Join Date: Aug 2018
Location: USA
Posts: 386
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by nimrod View Post
I have a Hot Ash mini stove titanium, and a jet boil titanium and a whisper international stove, ready for anything in the back country
you dont carry all three do you?
Reply With Quote
  #40  
Old 04-01-2019, 06:55 AM
nimrod's Avatar
nimrod nimrod is offline
 
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: Alberta for the most part
Posts: 2,810
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ronaround View Post
you dont carry all three do you?
No just the one that works for the trip/
Reply With Quote
  #41  
Old 04-01-2019, 08:45 AM
Wrongside Wrongside is offline
 
Join Date: Jun 2007
Posts: 1,084
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by cow-puncher View Post
Not sure if this is the right spot for this.
I am looking for a camp stove to put in my pack while hunting. I am looking at the Etekcity stove. It seems good but i am looking for recommendations from people who have used one lots.
Thanks
From my limited experience with them, I wouldn't bother. We purchased 3 to experiment with and eventually put in vehicle emergency kits. They seemed poorly made, but cheap and light, so worth trying... 1 of the 3 had a bad leak and was a blowtorch/rocket out the side. Fairly dangerous.

I'd stick with a quality brand name personally. It's not worth saving a couple bucks on gear, to potentially have reliability issues in the backcountry. I've used MSR and SOTO for years and their products have always performed well and been dependable. If there is ever a problem, MSR parts in particular are everywhere.

As others have mentioned, fuel consumption and weight become a factor on longer trips. One worthwhile upgrade to a backpack kitchen is a heat exchanger style pot or kettle. Much better efficiency, IME.
Reply With Quote
  #42  
Old 04-01-2019, 08:47 AM
graybeard graybeard is offline
 
Join Date: Oct 2009
Location: Calgary, AB
Posts: 2,122
Default

If you aren't in a rush, the Chapel will get a lot of various styles...

Because it is a seasonal item, we only had 5 at the last sale...Nothing over $10 at that sale.

http://www.outdoorsmenforum.ca/showthread.php?t=358866
__________________
Life is like baseball; it is the number of times you reach home safely, that counts.

We have two lives: The life we learn with and the life we live with after that.
Reply With Quote
  #43  
Old 04-01-2019, 09:58 AM
calgarychef calgarychef is offline
 
Join Date: Jul 2007
Posts: 6,667
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by graybeard View Post
If you aren't in a rush, the Chapel will get a lot of various styles...

Because it is a seasonal item, we only had 5 at the last sale...Nothing over $10 at that sale.

http://www.outdoorsmenforum.ca/showthread.php?t=358866
I had a couple in my hand at the sale but decided....I definitely don’t need another stove !
Reply With Quote
  #44  
Old 04-01-2019, 10:20 AM
Don_Parsons Don_Parsons is offline
 
Join Date: Jul 2016
Posts: 1,827
Default

Tin cup and wood,,, super light and easy to pack

👍
Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 10:32 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.5
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.