This comment isn't directed particularly at night hunting or it's supporters, but we always here "It's allowed in many jurisdictions" as reason for why it should be allowed here. I wonder what it would be like if we allowed everything that was allowed in every other regulated jurisdiction, all at once.
There is probably nothing inherently wrong with many individual practices, hunting over bait, night hunting, any weapon any season, using drones, using dogs, etc. etc. But if you allowed them all I suspect it might be carnage in the field. So each jusrisdiction picks and chooses hunting practices that it's hunting population feels comfortable with, often probably based on tradition. And given that we have a limited amount of game, each practice introduced which increases game harvest has to be offset by a decrease in tag numbers, access, etc. It has to end up being a zero sum game.