stupid judge

[FishingMOM]

Khadar can now wander freely.
No more monitoring him with a bracelet either.

http://www.calgaryherald.com/news/al...034/story.html

[Klondike]

Just wow.

But its no real surprise considering a guy goes from being an ambulance chaser held in low regard to the right honorable judge with the stroke of a politicians pen

[FishingMOM]

Originally Posted by Icatchfish

why you callin the judge stupid? would you like it if I called you stupid.

big meany

It's the politest thing I can come up with to express my feelings on this matter.

[deerguy]

Very biased pro khadr article. I am not impressed.

[artie]

at least now he can get to his prayers in the morning

[JustMe]

Yup, just like that guy that murdered that little girl this week.... They're both murderers and should be treated as such! Who nominated/placed this "judge?"

Originally Posted by Icatchfish

hes a a good kid who just made a mistake. cut him some slack

[deerhunter]

He does have 676 posts
Lol

[JustMe]

Excuse me??

Originally Posted by Icatchfish

sure, send that guy for 10 year to gitmo where he can be anally fed and water boarded, hypothermia tortured and locked in a cage. then bring him back.

at least this was a brain washed 14 yr old who was in an actual war situation. not a 22 year old who went into someones house and killed them, then murdered a 2 year old.

keep on bigotting buddy.

[Zuludog]

Hell in a hand basket.

[KGB]

Originally Posted by deerhunter

He does have 676 posts
Lol

I wouldn't be surprised if most of them are trolls... Only person in total denial can say things like this.

[Grizzly Adams]

Originally Posted by Icatchfish

why you callin the judge stupid? would you like it if I called you stupid.

big meany

I think that would put you in contempt of court, might be in Omar's cell if he hears about it. .

Grizz

[FishingMOM]

It is disturbing that we have a judge letting this guy having any freedom in Alberta and in Canada.

As a Canadian I am upset that we allow such scum wander our streets. I don't care he was 15. My 10 yr old knows right from wrong. So don't feed me bunk that he didn't know better.

I'm tired of our judges slapping murders on the wrist and saying bad boy, please play nice.

We got jasmine Richardson, ohmar khadar,
We are paying for both their educations and they are both free in Alberta.
Oh and for good measure we allow these turds to change their names

In documents filed in the Alberta Court of Appeal, Jeremy Steinke said he is now going by the name Jackson May. He was allowed to legally change his name.

Another example is Karla Holmoka who Changed it to Karla Teale

Sickening.

[Icatchfish]

Originally Posted by FishingMOM

It is disturbing that we have a judge letting this guy having any freedom in Alberta and in Canada.

As a Canadian I am upset that we allow such scum wander our streets. I don't care he was 15. My 10 yr old knows right from wrong. So don't feed me bunk that he didn't know better.

I'm tired of our judges slapping murders on the wrist and saying bad boy, please play nice.

We got jasmine Richardson, ohmar khadar,
We are paying for both their educations and they are both free in Alberta.
Oh and for good measure we allow these turds to change their names

In documents filed in the Alberta Court of Appeal, Jeremy Steinke said he is now going by the name Jackson May. He was allowed to legally change his name.

Another example is Karla Holmoka who Changed it to Karla Teale

Sickening.

Maybe your're a judge. But I have a slight susceptible that you work at 7/11. Leave the law to who knows it

[schmedlap]

your anger is totally misdirected at the Judge, and calling her "stupid" is just plain misinformed. Justice Ross is, as it happens, an excellent, smart, and conscientious judge, who does not let her own personal biases (which may fall on one side or the other here?) get in the way of her decisions. Do you not think she knows very well that this is not a "popular" decision? I can imagine her own personal distaste at even having to be the one assigned to handle the case - I'm quite sure there was no competition amongst judges to be assigned - quite the opposite - her reputation is likely to be smeared (as it is unjustly being by you and others here, on a very ignorant basis) no matter what she decides.

Personally, I think Khadr and his family are scum, I don't have the least sympathy for him, and I'd prefer to have seen him rot in prison forever. But the judge is duty bound, if he/she is the least interested in fulfilling his/her oath of office, to decipher and apply the law of Canada on such matters, as argued based on applicable statute and caselaw and contextual facts by, Khadr's lawyers on one side, and the government lawyers on the other. In very diligently doing so, she made her decision. She can't just "make it up as she goes" - if she does or did, the Court of Appeal will set her straight, and they might(?).

The blame for such results does not lie upon any judges, at all. It lies upon the legislators (Parliament) for the state of the law, and their failure to correct it, and/or upon the legal representatives of the government who were "overmatched" in their arguments by Khadr's lawyers. If you want to direct your anger at someone on this point, then start by asking your MP, or the relevant Minister, what they plan to do to alter the background laws that lead to such results.

[CNP]

Originally Posted by Icatchfish

Maybe your're a judge. But I have a slight susceptible that you work at 7/11. Leave the law to who knows it

Grade 4 English?

[kevinhits]

Originally Posted by Icatchfish

Maybe your're a judge. But I have a slight susceptible that you work at 7/11. Leave the law to who knows it

You need to retreat back to the fishing forum where you maybe belong....

[JohninAB]

Originally Posted by FishingMOM

It is disturbing that we have a judge letting this guy having any freedom in Alberta and in Canada.

As a Canadian I am upset that we allow such scum wander our streets. I don't care he was 15. My 10 yr old knows right from wrong. So don't feed me bunk that he didn't know better.

I'm tired of our judges slapping murders on the wrist and saying bad boy, please play nice.

We got jasmine Richardson, ohmar khadar,
We are paying for both their educations and they are both free in Alberta.
Oh and for good measure we allow these turds to change their names

In documents filed in the Alberta Court of Appeal, Jeremy Steinke said he is now going by the name Jackson May. He was allowed to legally change his name.

Another example is Karla Holmoka who Changed it to Karla Teale

Sickening.

Karla served her time.


If you do not like how this judge handled this case, then by all means, go and discuss it with the judge.

[huntsfurfish]

Originally Posted by schmedlap

your anger is totally misdirected at the Judge, and calling her "stupid" is just plain misinformed. Justice Ross is, as it happens, an excellent, smart, and conscientious judge, who does not let her own personal biases (which may fall on one side or the other here?) get in the way of her decisions. Do you not think she knows very well that this is not a "popular" decision? I can imagine her own personal distaste at even having to be the one assigned to handle the case - I'm quite sure there was no competition amongst judges to be assigned - quite the opposite - her reputation is likely to be smeared (as it is unjustly being by you and others here, on a very ignorant basis) no matter what she decides.

Personally, I think Khadr and his family are scum, I don't have the least sympathy for him, and I'd prefer to have seen him rot in prison forever. But the judge is duty bound, if he/she is the least interested in fulfilling his/her oath of office, to decipher and apply the law of Canada on such matters, as argued based on applicable statute and caselaw and contextual facts by, Khadr's lawyers on one side, and the government lawyers on the other. In very diligently doing so, she made her decision. She can't just "make it up as she goes" - if she does or did, the Court of Appeal will set her straight, and they might(?).

The blame for such results does not lie upon any judges, at all. It lies upon the legislators (Parliament) for the state of the law, and their failure to correct it, and/or upon the legal representatives of the government who were "overmatched" in their arguments by Khadr's lawyers. If you want to direct your anger at someone on this point, then start by asking your MP, or the relevant Minister, what they plan to do to alter the background laws that lead to such results.

Very well said!

[Weedy1]

Originally Posted by schmedlap

your anger is totally misdirected at the Judge, and calling her "stupid" is just plain misinformed. Justice Ross is, as it happens, an excellent, smart, and conscientious judge, who does not let her own personal biases (which may fall on one side or the other here?) get in the way of her decisions. Do you not think she knows very well that this is not a "popular" decision? I can imagine her own personal distaste at even having to be the one assigned to handle the case - I'm quite sure there was no competition amongst judges to be assigned - quite the opposite - her reputation is likely to be smeared (as it is unjustly being by you and others here, on a very ignorant basis) no matter what she decides.

Personally, I think Khadr and his family are scum, I don't have the least sympathy for him, and I'd prefer to have seen him rot in prison forever. But the judge is duty bound, if he/she is the least interested in fulfilling his/her oath of office, to decipher and apply the law of Canada on such matters, as argued based on applicable statute and caselaw and contextual facts by, Khadr's lawyers on one side, and the government lawyers on the other. In very diligently doing so, she made her decision. She can't just "make it up as she goes" - if she does or did, the Court of Appeal will set her straight, and they might(?).

The blame for such results does not lie upon any judges, at all. It lies upon the legislators (Parliament) for the state of the law, and their failure to correct it, and/or upon the legal representatives of the government who were "overmatched" in their arguments by Khadr's lawyers. If you want to direct your anger at someone on this point, then start by asking your MP, or the relevant Minister, what they plan to do to alter the background laws that lead to such results.

Thank you!

[Headdamage]

There are a lot of people the courts let out on the streets that I'm more concerned about than a guy that did something in another country when he was 14 years old.

[deerguy]

Originally Posted by Headdamage

There are a lot of people the courts let out on the streets that I'm more concerned about than a guy that did something in another country when he was 14 years old.

He is an afghani terrorist, he should have been shot by the Americans back in his homeland.

[nenaj]

Originally Posted by deerguy

He is an afghani terrorist, he should have been shot by the Americans back in his homeland.

Huh? His homeland is Canada.

[purgatory.sv]

Originally Posted by schmedlap

your anger is totally misdirected at the Judge, and calling her "stupid" is just plain misinformed. Justice Ross is, as it happens, an excellent, smart, and conscientious judge, who does not let her own personal biases (which may fall on one side or the other here?) get in the way of her decisions. Do you not think she knows very well that this is not a "popular" decision? I can imagine her own personal distaste at even having to be the one assigned to handle the case - I'm quite sure there was no competition amongst judges to be assigned - quite the opposite - her reputation is likely to be smeared (as it is unjustly being by you and others here, on a very ignorant basis) no matter what she decides.

Personally, I think Khadr and his family are scum, I don't have the least sympathy for him, and I'd prefer to have seen him rot in prison forever. But the judge is duty bound, if he/she is the least interested in fulfilling his/her oath of office, to decipher and apply the law of Canada on such matters, as argued based on applicable statute and caselaw and contextual facts by, Khadr's lawyers on one side, and the government lawyers on the other. In very diligently doing so, she made her decision. She can't just "make it up as she goes" - if she does or did, the Court of Appeal will set her straight, and they might(?).

The blame for such results does not lie upon any judges, at all. It lies upon the legislators (Parliament) for the state of the law, and their failure to correct it, and/or upon the legal representatives of the government who were "overmatched" in their arguments by Khadr's lawyers. If you want to direct your anger at someone on this point, then start by asking your MP, or the relevant Minister, what they plan to do to alter the background laws that lead to such results.

I do not always agree with what you post.
But this is true.
If they do not always agree they will qualify.

[ETOWNCANUCK]

This is Canada

We have a legal system
Not a justice system

And on that note were he in front of a judge not in Canada his fate most certainly would have been different at this stage of his legal matters

Kid you not
Our system is a joke and decades will pass and governing parties will come and go with nary much change.

[roper1]

Originally Posted by schmedlap

your anger is totally misdirected at the Judge, and calling her "stupid" is just plain misinformed. Justice Ross is, as it happens, an excellent, smart, and conscientious judge, who does not let her own personal biases (which may fall on one side or the other here?) get in the way of her decisions. Do you not think she knows very well that this is not a "popular" decision? I can imagine her own personal distaste at even having to be the one assigned to handle the case - I'm quite sure there was no competition amongst judges to be assigned - quite the opposite - her reputation is likely to be smeared (as it is unjustly being by you and others here, on a very ignorant basis) no matter what she decides.

Personally, I think Khadr and his family are scum, I don't have the least sympathy for him, and I'd prefer to have seen him rot in prison forever. But the judge is duty bound, if he/she is the least interested in fulfilling his/her oath of office, to decipher and apply the law of Canada on such matters, as argued based on applicable statute and caselaw and contextual facts by, Khadr's lawyers on one side, and the government lawyers on the other. In very diligently doing so, she made her decision. She can't just "make it up as she goes" - if she does or did, the Court of Appeal will set her straight, and they might(?).

The blame for such results does not lie upon any judges, at all. It lies upon the legislators (Parliament) for the state of the law, and their failure to correct it, and/or upon the legal representatives of the government who were "overmatched" in their arguments by Khadr's lawyers. If you want to direct your anger at someone on this point, then start by asking your MP, or the relevant Minister, what they plan to do to alter the background laws that lead to such results.

Gotta disagree here buddy, she can't be jim-dandy, excellent, smart, conscientious, etc., on one hand.....then have Khadr's lawyer overmatch the gov't schmuck. She is either bright enough to see the forest for the trees ...or not!! To say she is blameless is silly, she is paid to make a decision, she won't always make the correct one.......

[purgatory.sv]

Originally Posted by ETOWNCANUCK

This is Canada

We have a legal system
Not a justice system

And on that note were he in front of a judge not in Canada his fate most certainly would have been different at this stage of his legal matters

Kid you not
Our system is a joke and decades will pass and governing parties will come and go with nary much change.

Yes what you have said is true.

That is why fire can be good.

But only in your domain.

[FishingMOM]

I still stand in my belief that the judge was stupid in giving this scumbag terrorist freedom to wander Canada and speak freely. We no longer have the ability to monitor his actions.

The US government should take him back into custody since Canada isn't holding him. He doesn't belong here. He really belongs with daddy 6 feet under.

[trooper]

Originally Posted by nenaj

Huh? His homeland is Canada.

Okay, than shoot him here! My solution.

[elkhunter11]

Originally Posted by nenaj

Huh? His homeland is Canada.

Any Canadian that takes up arms against Canada's ally in a conflict is a traitor. As such he should have been hung or shot.

[58thecat]

I prefer the raging judge as my public defender.
No court, no jury, no wasted tax payers dollars.