270 vs 7mm-08

[Chevy 454]

Wow. I just read this whole thread and for all your smugness and holier than thou attitude, I still have absolutely no idea what point you are trying to make!

[elkhunter11]

Originally Posted by Rpm5

Last time I checked they didn't make a Sendaro in 270 win.

Remington most certainly did sell the Sendero in 270win. It wasn't one of the popular chamberings, so they didn't continue to offer it in the Sendero II SF.

[Okotokian]

Originally Posted by Chevy 454

Wow. I just read this whole thread and for all your smugness and holier than thou attitude, I still have absolutely no idea what point you are trying to make!

Everyone agrees either round can kill a moose at reasonable ranges. They are just arguing now about which kills the moose more.

[Kauna]

Originally Posted by Okotokian

Everyone agrees either round can kill a moose at reasonable ranges. They are just arguing now about which kills the moose more.

No one agreed to that ...270 win all day long vs 7-08..lol unless you tell the OP and me the diff ....penetration , velocity , SD and bullet weight ..am lost here..in my experience the 270 win has outdone the 7-08 at moose camps every year all the time...have seen 12 bull moose fallen to the 270

[Pathfinder76]

Originally Posted by Kauna

.am lost here

Now that I can agree with!

[Kauna]

Originally Posted by chuck

Now that I can agree with!

....jack %%^

[Kauna]

Originally Posted by chuck

Now that I can agree with!

dear Chuck ..can you explain the diff / performance of a tiny 7-08 and and the 30-06 on moose ..or have you ever shot one ???? either the rifle or moose ...lol

[Pathfinder76]

Originally Posted by Kauna

dear Chuck ..can you explain the diff / performance of a tiny 7-08 and athe 30-06 on moose ..or have you ever shot one ????

You got me there. I defer to your expertise. Complete with photos please.

[Kauna]

Originally Posted by chuck

You got me there. I defer to your expertise. Complete with photos please.

again ...

[Pathfinder76]

And I said, I've never shot a moose nor pulled the trigger on a 30-06 or 7mm-08. You?

[Kauna]

Originally Posted by chuck

And I said, I've never shot a moose nor pulled the trigger on a 30-06 or 7mm-08. You?

have shot 5 moose with the 7-08 ..they all ran away..used the 140 gr AB

[Kurt505]

Originally Posted by Kauna

have shot 5 moose with the 7-08 ..they all ran away..used the 140 gr AB

Well there's your problem right there. Bad shot.

[Kauna]

Originally Posted by Kurt505

Well there's your problem right there. Bad shot.

...

[elkhunter11]

Originally Posted by Kauna

have shot 5 moose with the 7-08 ..they all ran away..used the 140 gr AB

If you shot five moose with a 7mm-08, and they all ran away, the cartridge isn't the problem, the person pulling the trigger is the problem.

[Kauna]

Originally Posted by elkhunter11

If you shot five moose with a 7mm-08, and they all ran away, the cartridge isn't the problem, the person pulling the trigger is the problem.

thanks for that advise ..now I will quit hunting ....it was actually 7 moose

[bat119]

160 posts about a piece of lead covered in copper varying by .011" flying at
+\- 100 FPS

Reminds of the 3 monks that could only speak one sentence a year
1st monk I like my potatoes fried
a year later 2nd monk I like my potatoes boiled
a year later 3rd monk I wish you two would quit this constant bickering

[coolpete1]

Originally Posted by Kauna

have shot 5 moose with the 7-08 ..they all ran away..used the 140 gr AB

you might wanna stick to gophers man.

[Kauna]

Originally Posted by coolpete1

you might wanna stick to gophers man.

tried that ..the badgers came and ate them all ..so back to the 7-08 loosing 7 moose ? and idea's

[Kauna]

Originally Posted by bat119

160 posts about a piece of lead covered in copper varying by .011" flying at
+\- 100 FPS

Reminds of the 3 monks that could only speak one sentence a year
1st monk I like my potatoes fried
a year later 2nd monk I like my potatoes boiled
a year later 3rd monk I wish you two would quit this constant bickering

well MONK ..speak up ..are u potatoes or lead ? ..lol

[roger]

Originally Posted by bat119

160 posts about a piece of lead covered in copper varying by .011" flying at
+\- 100 FPS

Reminds of the 3 monks that could only speak one sentence a year
1st monk I like my potatoes fried
a year later 2nd monk I like my potatoes boiled
a year later 3rd monk I wish you two would quit this constant bickering

Obviously all three were chipmunks!

[Kauna]

Originally Posted by roger

both the 270 and 7mm08 are great girls starter guns and can be found in the "Junior Miss" section of any decent sporting goods store, just ask for a step-stool to see over the gun counter.
who cares what other people think about your 'cutesy' calibers as long your secure with that lifestyle choice.
Any hairy-chested hunter/gather knows it has say MAGNUM before anything dies!!


(actually cut and paste what elkhunter11 said here)

na ..took your advise and shot a few chipmunks ....hope you don't have any daughters..again you rule

[tchardy1972]

This thread just gave me a head ache. A question for kauna, how big of a cartridge would be needed to drive that 140 grain accubond fast enough to kill a moose with one shot? My experience with moose is that they are not overly tough animals I have seen several killed with a single from cartridges smaller than the ones in question.

[Kauna]

Originally Posted by tchardy1972

This thread just gave me a head ache. A question for kauna, how big of a cartridge would be needed to drive that 140 grain accubond fast enough to kill a moose with one shot?

wholly chit ..been asking that all along ..so tell us ..willa 7-08 work..straight answer is yes somewhat ..270 win works better..there you go

[tchardy1972]

Originally Posted by Kauna

wholly chit ..been asking that all along ..so tell us ..willa 7-08 work

You would think after loosing the first one or maybe even two moose you would have tried to fix or change something. Or just practice basic marksmanship?

[catnthehat]

Originally Posted by Kauna

thanks for that advise ..now I will quit hunting ....it was actually 7 moose

You are either the World's worst shot or one of AO's biggest liars.
Cat

[Kauna]

Originally Posted by tchardy1972

You would think after loosing the first one or maybe even two moose you would have tried to fix or change something. Or just practice basic marksmanship?

I can't hit a barn door , so I think bigger is better ...also lost 4 elk and 8 deer with that damn 7-08

[Kurt505]

Originally Posted by catnthehat

You are either the World's worst shot or one of AO's biggest liars.
C at

Savin face.

[Kauna]

Originally Posted by Kurt505

Savin face.

the 270 win rules all day long ....never lost any game with it

[catnthehat]

Originally Posted by Kauna

the 270 win rules all day long ....never lost any game with it

So 200FPS at the muzzle and 300FPE is going to make the difference between a lost animal and a killed animal?
Don't think so Bubba, try your BS elsewhere, everybody here as pretty much written you off as a troll.
Cat

[Kurt505]

Originally Posted by Kauna

the 270 win rules all day long ....never lost any game with it

Ya...... That's what I hear.